Posidrive or slotted screws for woodwork?

Er no. The visual effect of a slotted screw is *objectively* different from the visual effect of a posidrive or other cross head, torx or hex head..

What is subjective and so trivially and obvious that its not worth mentioning, is whether you care or not.

Reply to
The Natural Philosopher
Loading thread data ...

Because they don't look old?

Reply to
Mr Macaw

I don't get pozidrive falling out. As long as the screwdriver is perpendicular, and you're applying a downward force on it. I guess torx are tougher, but I'd think you could put in more pozis a minute.

I don't understand Philips still existing at all. Pozidrive is basically Phillips.1.

Reply to
Mr Macaw

Isn't that silver instead of gold colour?

Reply to
Mr Macaw

[searches] You get brass plated ones though.
Reply to
Mr Macaw

Errr, I though galvanised stuff never rusted. Sacrificial protection and all that.

Reply to
Mr Macaw

And if your driver isn't aligned, you only have to turn it a maximum of

60 degrees (as against 90 for pozi/Philips, and 180 for slotted screws).
Reply to
polygonum

As with everything, too many inbetweens. For example, why does a car need 5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20mm bolts? Why not just 5, 8, 11, 14, 17, 20?

Reply to
Mr Macaw

No, what is subjective is whether you prefer the look of pozidrive or straight.

Reply to
Mr Macaw

But pozi screws allow it to drop in when it aligns, so you just start turning gently until it drops in.

Straight wouldn't be so bad if the groove stopped before the edge of the screw. The main problem is the driver slides out the side.

Reply to
Mr Macaw

The sme reason as why the Rolls Royce Meriln engine used a 3BA bolt in one situation - because it was the correct engineering solution

Malcolm

Reply to
Malcolm Race

And I am pretty sure most cars manage with about half a dozen. Typically

10, 13, and 15 rather than 11 and 14.
Reply to
newshound

You don't need that many numbers. Where do you draw the line? A 3.78294572138mm bolt?

Reply to
Mr Macaw

Exactly.

Reply to
newshound

I thought decent antique stuff had all the screws hidden anyway.

Reply to
Mr Macaw

Having done a fair amount of design, frankly 'the correct engineering solution' is a load of twaddle. 99.7% of engineering is 'good enough' - not 'exactly right'

There is a huge pressure to reduce stock inventory as well. which is why having a special screw that is M 5.638 or somesuch might just happen in a space mission, but nowhere else not even a Merlin engine.

3BA wasn't that common, but it was a standard.

Most cars do NOT use a zillion different bolts either. probably no more than half a dozen in any given car..however the next manufacturer whose car you fix, has a completely different half dozen. His inventory is different,

Reply to
The Natural Philosopher

A number of my old woodwork teachers who were "old school" cabinet makers insisted that slotted screws in close proximity to each other or on adjacent hinges had their slots aligned.

Richard

Reply to
Tricky Dicky

I thought everybody did that - I made all the screws in my wall sockets horizontal. Pozis don't matter so much.

To not do so is similar to having your furniture scattered randomly around the room instead of in line with the wall.

Reply to
Mr Macaw

I attempted to change to Torx screws but found that I needed 3 different size bits, whereas with PZ a No2 fitted the whole range.

Reply to
David Lang

Almost everything that needs fixing to a wall includes Phillips screws. They drive me mad, first thing I do is to throw them away.

Reply to
David Lang

HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.