Tips for dealing with a botched furnace install in a rental that nobody talks about

Nov 17, 2026 Last reply: 1 day ago 4 Replies
Saved reading
Jump to replies (4)

Been thru this exact headache a few years back as a tenant, so here's what actualy worked for me. First, document everything. Take clear photos of every questionable connection, any open or disconnected duct, the exhaust piping, all of it. Date the photos. Then keep a simple log of what the house feels like, rooms that never warm up, the thermostat cycling weird, whatever you notice day to day. Second, and this is the big one, don't let the landlord just send the original installer back out. That never goes anywhere. What worked for me was politely asking the landlord if a second oppinion could be brought in, framing it as protecting the property, not criticizing anyone. Most towns require a permit and an inspection for furnace work, so a call to the local building department can settle a lot of questions fast. If the inspection gets scheduled, the original contractor has to make things right on thier own dime.



Also, keep copies of your utility bills from before and after the install. Landlords respond to numbers. If your gas or electric usage jumped after the work was done, that's evidence the system isn't running right, and it strengthens your case for bringing in someone else. None of this is confrontational if you present it as helping the landlord avoid a repeat, and in my case the second contractor found the first guy had never even sealed the joints properly.


Similar boat here, though I was the homeowner when my 80% furnace got swapped out two winters ago. The crew left before the first cold snap and my January bill came in way higher than the same month the year before, even though the new unit was supposed to be more efficient. Turns out they had reused the old return duct layout without resizing anything, so the blower was fighting a starving return and short cycling constantly.

The thing that actually got movement was calling the permit office myself. My town had the permit on file, and once I mentioned an inspection request, the original contractor suddenly had time to come back. They added a proper return path and set the fan speed correctly, and my gas usage dropped noticeably the very next month.

One thing I whould add to the utility bill advice: pull the degree day data for your area or just compare months with similar weather, because a colder stretch can mask or exaggerate a bad install. My first comparison was misleading untill I checked the heating days.

Also worth keeping the model and serial numbers of the new unit written down somewhere. When the second company came out, they spotted on the spot that the unit was rated lower than what the sales quote had promised, which gave me real leverage on the make-good work.

Been fixing and replacing furnaces since the days when a guy would stay and watch the first firing, so hearing about crews vanishing the same day always makes me chuckle. One thing I'd tell anyone with a fresh install: go down there when it kicks on and just listen and smell. A new furnace should run smooth, no rattling, no whiff of exhaust in the house. Back then we'd check the draft with a plain match flame near the flue hood, old trick but it still tells you plenty. Also ask to see the paperwork before the crew leaves. If they get twitchy about it, that's your sign something's off.

Gotta push back on the permit office being the fix-all here. I called mine when I thougth my install was sloppy and the inspector came out, checked for gas leaks and clearances, and passed it. That was it. They don't judge wheather the ducts were resized right or the unit was sized properly, they check code and safety. Contractor used the pass sticker to tell me everything was fine and I was back to square one. What actually got results was paying an independent tech for a combustion and airflow check, then handing that report to the installer. Cost me a couple hundred bucks but it ended the back and forth.

Update: finally got the second opinion out last week. Took the vet's advice and just stood there listening when it kicked on, and you could hear air whistling where it shouldn't. Turns out one duct run was never attached and the flue wasn't pitched right. Also fair point from whoever said the permit inspector only checks basics, beacuse this thing passed first time. Landlord's covering the redo.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required