Is it ok that my landlord DIY'd our new wall furnace install?

Nov 18, 2026 Last reply: 1 day ago 4 Replies
Saved reading

First reply

BuilderSummit

Yes, get a licensed tech out, and do it before you're running this thing every day. Gas wall furnaces are one of those appliances where the install matters as much as the unit itself, and what you're describing breaks several rules that exist for good reasons. The zero gap…

Read the full reply

So our old wall furnace finally quit and instead of calling a proper installer, my landlord decided she'd handle the new one herself. She watched some videos and went at it over a weekend. The thing heats fine now but the whole setup looks off to me and I want a second oppinion before winter really kicks in. The unit sits really tight against the wall, no gap behind it at all, and she just screwed it flat to the wall without any brackets. The exhaust pipe goes up through a hole she cut into the cabinet above it, and the ducting is held on with what looks like foil tape and hope. She also couldn't get the new thermostat to pair with the wires from the old one so she ran completley fresh wire across the kitchen wall instead of using the existing hole. Should I be pushing her to get a licensed tech out to look at it? It's a gas unit, which is what worries me most. If she has to redo it because someone finds a problem, I'd rather know now than smell somthing weird at 2am in January. What would count as an automatic call-a-pro red flag here, other than the obvious stuff?


Yes, get a licensed tech out, and do it before you're running this thing every day. Gas wall furnaces are one of those appliances where the install matters as much as the unit itself, and what you're describing breaks several rules that exist for good reasons.

The zero gap behind the unit is a big one. Every wall furnace manual lists a required clearance to combustibles, and the cabinet gets genuinely hot in operation. She shoud have followed that spec to the inch, and since she aparently never opened a manual, there's no reason to think she did. Screwing the cabinet flat to the wall is also wrong on its own. These units are meant to hang on a bracket or strap so they can be pulled forward for service, and driving screws through the cabinet risks hitting internal components. The venting is the part that would scare me most. The exhaust should connect to a collar on the furnace and run through listed vent pipe to a proper chimney or vent, with joints mechanically fastened and sealed the way the manual says. Foil tape holding ductwork togehter is not that, and a hole cut into the cabinet above the unit means there's a real chance exhaust is dumping into the wall cavity instead of going outside. That's the 2am scenario you're worried about.

The thermostat wire across the kitchen wall is low voltage so it's mostly cosmetic, but it tells you she couldn't follow a wiring diagram, and miswiring a gas valve circuit can leave a burner running when it shouldn't. One more angle for convincing her: in most places a gas appliance replacement legally requires a permit and inspection, sometimes by a licensed fitter. If there's ever a fire or a CO incident and there's no permit, her insurance could walk away. Frame it as one service call now versus her whole liability later. Ask her for the installation manual and the permit paperwork. If she can't produce either, that answers your question.

Had a similar thing with my old man years back, he swapped his own wall furnace and swore it ran fine. Tech came out for something else and found the draft hood was never seated right, been spilling a little exhaust the whole time. You can't smell that stuff untill it's bad. I'd grab a CO detector for that room today if you don't alredy have one, cheap insurance while you wait on the inspection. Also worth checking if her unit's warranty is even valid with a DIY install, most aren't.

One thing I'd add is the gas connection itself. Did she put fresh thread compound on the fittings and actually check for leaks? It's a two minute job with some soapy water on the joints, bubbles mean a leak, but you'd be amazed how many DIY installs skip it. Also worth asking if she leveled the unit, these need to sit plumb or the burner doesn't burn right. If she got defensive when you asked about the venting, that tells you plenty already.

Update: ran the soapy water trick from the last reply on every joint I could reach, no bubbles at least. Grabbed a CO detector on the way home and it's been silent so far. Still pushing her on a proper tech before winter. One thing I noticed tonight though, the cabinet above the unit feels warm when it runs. Is that normal or should I be worried?

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required