After a month of collecting numbers I finally signed with a contractor to replace the steam boiler in my old house. Figured I'd share what the process acutally looked like since the sticker shock hit me hard at first. The first quote came in and I honestly laughed out loud. Thought they were including a vacation home or something. Second quote was close to it. I almost gave up til a neighbor mentioned that the labor is the real cost, not the box itself. Old steam systems take serious time to cut out and pipe back up correctly, and the near-boiler piping has to be redone right or you get water hammer forever.
What actually moved the needle for me was asking each contractor how they'd size the replacement. The one I hired measured every radiator in the house and checked my insulation before giving a final number. The lazy ones just quoted off the old nameplate. Big difference in confidence.
One quote included removing what turned out to be old boiler insulation that needed proper handling, which added real money but was non-negotiable. So if your number seems crazy, ask what's bundled in. Mine wasn't padding, it was just an honest job on an honest old house.