Is it normal for boiler pressure to climb when the heat kicks on?

Nov 09, 2026 Last reply: 5 days ago 3 Replies
Saved reading

First reply

Jen_Frost_1968

15 psi cold is right where it shoud be, so don't worry about that number. The creep up to 25 when it's been running is the part to look at, and nine times out of ten that's a waterlogged expansion tank. The tank's job is to give the heated water somewhere to expand into, and…

Read the full reply

So I've got a gas boiler with baseboard hot water heat that came with the house, probly 18 or 20 years old, no paperwork to say for sure. Last couple weeks I've noticed the pressure gauge sitting around 15 psi cold, but after the heat's been running a while it creeps up to almost 25. Radiators upstairs have also been clanging pretty loud when it first fires up. I figured that was just old pipes doing thier thing untill a buddy said climbing pressure might mean something worse.


15 psi cold is right where it shoud be, so don't worry about that number. The creep up to 25 when it's been running is the part to look at, and nine times out of ten that's a waterlogged expansion tank. The tank's job is to give the heated water somewhere to expand into, and when the bladder inside goes bad it fills with water and can't absorb the pressure anymore. Your system has no place to go with that expansion, so the needle climbs. ussually the safety valve on the boiler dumps water around 30 psi, so you're getting close to where it'll spit on the floor every heat cycle.

Easy check you can do yourself: tap the tank with something like a wrench handle. The top half should sound hollow, the bottom half solid. If the whole thing thuds like it's full of water, the bladder's shot. There's also a little valve on top like a tire valve, and if water comes out when you press the pin instead of air, that confirms it.

The clanging upstairs is probably related. When the pressure gets wierd or the tank's waterlogged, you get air pockets in the loops, and baseboard hammering at startup is classic trapped air. Bleeding the baseboard loops after the tank gets sorted usually quiets that right down.

Don't let anybody talk you into replacing an 18-20 year old boiler over this. A tank swap is a couple hundred bucks of parts and maybe an hour of labor if you get someone in. Cast iron boilers that age with no leaks and decent pressure cold are often good for another decade or more with a yearly tuneup. Get an independent plumber to look at it before you even think about a replacement quote.

First post here so hope this lands ok, but this thread is basially describing my house too. Mine's a similar age system except mine's acutally a furnace with ducts, so I don't have a tank like yours at all, wich is why I'm probably no help. The thing I'd want to know before calling anyone: is swapping that tank a DIY job or does it need draining the whole system first? I watched a video on it and got nervous halfway through. Also curious if the tank needs its air charge set to anything specific when it goes in, or if it comes pre-set out of the box.

One thing to add on the tank check, if it turns out the bladder is still good, verify the air charge on the tank side rather than assuming. You have to isolate the tank and drain the water side of it first, becuase reading the pressure with the system connected just tells you what the boiler is doing, not what the tank is holding. If the charge has drifted low over the years the tank can act half waterlogged even with an intact bladder, and pumping it back up to match your fill pressure with a bike pump fixes it in ten minutes. Also worth knowing the little schrader cap should be kept on, they tend to seize up without it.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required