Cleaned up the rust in my burner compartment this weekend and fired it back up

Nov 19, 2026 Last reply: 21 hours ago 5 Replies
Saved reading
Jump to replies (5)

Spent Saturday morning dealing with the rust on the furnace floor where that condensate leak had been dripping. Tech fixed the leak a couple weeks back, so the source was gone, I just had to deal with the mess it left. Wire brushed the flaky stuff off, wiped it down with vinegar, then let it sit with a fan on it overnight to make sure there was zero moisture left in there. Painted it Sunday with a high temp rust converter primer I found at the hardware store, brushed on in two thin coats since I didn't want drips pooling anywhere near the burner. Left the furnace off all day while it cured, then put the panel back on and ran a full heat cycle that evening. Everything sounded normal, no smells other than a faint paint odor for the first few minutes that faded fast.



While I had it open I pulled the flame sensor and gave it a light scrub too, since I was in there anyway. Ignition's actually snappier now than it was before.



For what it's worth, the company that did the leak repair also tried to sell me a whole new furnace while they were at it. Unit's about a decade old, but it's been reliable otherwise, so I'm going to run it and see. Glad I fixed it myself for the cost of a brush and a small can of primer instead.


Did pretty much the same thing on my Carrier about four years back after a slow drip from the AC coil above the furnace had rusted the floor pan. Wire brush, vinegar wipe, and one of those rust converting primers from the local supply house. That was three heating seasons ago and the patch is still holding, no new flaking when I pull the panel for the annual filter change.

The one thing I'd keep an eye on is where the rust was relative to the burners and the heat exchanger. Mine was on the floor pan only, which is basically cosmetic once it's sealed. If you're seeing rust anywhere on the exchanger itself or around the burner tubes, that's when a tech's opinion actually means something, because that's the part that matters for how the furnace runs.

Also went through the same sales pitch on a replacement. Guy quoted me something like triple what the repair cost and told me a ten year old unit was 'on borrowed time.' Mine's fifteen now and humming along. Ten years is around when parts start needing attention, not when the whole thing dies. The flame sensor scrub is a good habit anyway. I do mine every fall now with a dollar bill folded around it, takes two minutes and my ignition has been reliable ever since.

My expirience with furnace floor rust went sideways the first time because I rushed the prep. Had a Rheem where the humidifier had been dripping for who knows how long before I noticed. Did the brush and paint thing without sanding past the loose stuff, and by the following winter the paint was lifting in little bubbles. Turns out rust converter primer needs clean bare metal to actually bond, at least in my case. Redid it the next summer with a wire cup on a drill, sanded untill I saw shiny steel, then wiped with mineral spirits and painted. That second attempt has held for five seasons now.

On the replace-or-run-it question, I'd add that a second opinon from an independent guy is worth the service call fee. The outfit that found my leak quoted me a full swap too, and then a solo tech I called for a tuneup looked at the same furnace and said it had plenty of years left. Big difference in what they charge versus what they install. One thing I do now is peek under the panel every fall when I change the filter. Takes thirty seconds and if I see anything starting to bubble or flake again I catch it while it's still small.

First time posting here so hope this goes in the right spot. I'm prepping for basially the same job but mine came from a cracked humidifier drain hose, so the rust is up the side wall of the cabinet a bit instead of on the floor. My worry is painting anywhere close to the gas valve and pilot area, the patch ends a few inches from it. Did anyone cover things off before brushing, or is the burner compartment far enough away that it's not an issue? Mine's around the same age as the OP's and the HVAC guy pushed a quote on me last month too, so reading this thread is honestly a relief.

That takes me back. In the 80s we used to sand a rust spot down, wipe it with kerosene to displace the water, and hit it with whatever paint was on the shelf. Half those patches outlived the furnaces. One trick the old service guys taught me: drag a fridge magnet across the rusted area after you've cleaned it. If the magnet still grabs solid, the metal's got enough left to bother painting. If it's soft or punky under the brush, you're just covering a hole. Might be worth checking yours before winter so you know what you actually patched. How thick was the flaking where the drip landed?

Update: that fridge magnet trick from the older post actualy worked, it caught some flaking I'd missed under the burner area, so I wire brushed and repainted that spot. But now I'm noticing a slight give in the floor pan right where the burner sits. Is a soft spot like that something the cabinet can live with, or does it mean the metal's done for?

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required