Had our furnace checked last week before the heating season kicks off, and now I'm second guessing everything the guy told us. He said the gas valve was corroded shut and he had to force it open, and that the CO in the vent was jumping around and sitting above the 100 ppm legal limit, spiking close to 300 at one point. Because of that, he says he had to legally condemn the furnace.
Then he went out to his truck, supposedly to call his sales team, came back with two replacement quotes. When I asked what actually caused the problem, all he said was 'the heat exchanger ussually.' I asked about repairing it instead and he just said it's shot and they wouldn't touch it. He left with no paperwork, no tag or anything written on the furnace, nothing for us to sign, and they still haven't sent the actual quote. The furnace is only 10 years old, which feels like it should still have life in it, and with no real evidence the heat exchanger is bad I keep wondering if replacement is even necessery. Money is tight, we can't easily swing another inspection fee, and financing isn't a good option for me right now. If I do get a second opinon, what should I be asking to make sure it's legit?