I just now accidentally found this topic while "googling"and although the forum happened months ago, I have to add my comments. I have a Ryobi AP-10 planer that I bought when they first hit the market years ago. I have run literally thousands of feet of rough cut lumber as well as dimensioned, through it....no that's NOTan exaggeration.....and have never replaced a single part. It's been used and abused. I have rarely even sharpened the blades and most of the time they needed it. But due to my laziness, I just wanted to get the boards planed. This of course, adds to the strain on the planer, but it just keeps on "hogging" it's way through. It has been probably the most reliable tool in my shop. In recent times I find myself "drooling" on the new wider planers. That is until I look at the quality, price tags and disposable blades. I wish it was wider than ten inches, but it's not. But I have never been sorry that I bought it.
At the same time I bought a Ryobi orbital jig saw. Although it hasn't seen nearly as much use, I can say the same for it.
No. In my opinion, no, they haven't always been junk.
:D
:D