Mattress pad vs. new mattress

My old mattress is well worn. I probably should buy a new one but hate to think of the fuss and scheduling to remove and deliver a new mattress plus tearing apart the bedding and putting it back. And the expense! Seems like a mattress pad would give me most of the advantages and few of the problems. What has been your experience? If so, how thick? Filled with what? Any particularly good brands?

TIA

Reply to
KenK
Loading thread data ...

Nothing will upgrade an old mattress better than a new mattress. The technology has changed considerably and no "mattress pad" is going to improve the worn springs and degraded padding in an old mattress.

That said, you might want to consider something like this:

formatting link

Reply to
DerbyDad03

In my opinion, waveless waterbeds are the best.

formatting link

I hate trying to sleep on a typical hotel/conventional mattress.

Reply to
Darrel

Bingo, when my wife and I visit my mother-in-law, she has downsized to an apartment, we get the bed that pulls out of a couch, must be the most uncomfortable thing ever invented. She got a three inch memory foam pad, we put it over the existing mattress, much better.

Reply to
FrozenNorth

I did one recently. Nobody wanted to deliver and take old bed so I arranged for trash hauler to pickup old mattress and box springs for $15. New bed was brought in and assembled. I'm too old for doing all this myself but it was easy to drag old stuff downstairs and out to trash. Did have a problem with Waste Management because they quoted $15 on line and $45 over the phone but I ended up with the lower.

Reply to
Frank

+1, been sleeping on one for almost 30 years. But not that brand and no way NEAR that price.
+1 again, they are hard as a rock.
Reply to
dadiOH

I have never met a pull-out couch that I liked. The mattresses don't amount to much more than a couple of blankets on top of some very sharp springs.

We recently stayed in a hotel with a king sized bed and a pull-out couch. My daughter joined us for one night so I let SWMBO and her have the bed and I took the couch. After 10 minutes I folded it back up and piled the cushions, pillows and spare blankets on the floor. The mattress from the couch was un-sleepable.

The only pull-out that comes close to being comfortable is this one:

formatting link

My daughter used it in her apartment for a month while she waited for her "furnished roommate" to move in. Yes, it's an inflatable couch.

Reply to
DerbyDad03

Yep, the three inch memory foam on top makes it bearable, but they are hard to store and bring out in an apartment, they weigh more than a mattress, at least in a queen size. Couple bungie cords and we can tie it up after a fold and roll, but it isn't the easiest thing to do, as it will not fold up into the couch.

Reply to
FrozenNorth

A mattress pad will conform to the sinking mattress and defeat the purpose. If it was a flat sturdy surface, I mattress pad will help. Your best option is a full mattress.

We've had the Temperpedic for many years now even though I was content with a common spring mattress (Wife's choice). In time, even the temperpedic has a small indent in the same spot we lie. There are varying degrees of firmness and thickness. I think we have the 10". The memory foam holds heat since it also uses your body heat to form to it. Thus, if your body runs hot, you may not like them, unless you can sleep with just a bed spread over you.

I suggest you visit every mattress store in your area that offers different type of mattresses. Though, sometimes that can be more confusing. We demoed many types from foam, water, hybrids and air and the main issue they all had was high price. The confusing part is they all feel great when you're lying on it in a store, but process of elimination reduces the rough ones. The real test is long term. If I were single, I would have stayed with the innerspring type.

Reply to
Meanie

You just can't be a good night's sleep. We bought this and really like it. My wife had some issues after surgery and had to spend some time in bed. I used to hate to watch TV in bed but with this, it is as comfortable as sitting in a recliner. Then push a button and go to sleep on a level bed.

Be kind to yourself and do it right.

formatting link

Reply to
Ed Pawlowski

And not only that, they're going to sell you a box spring by saying there is no guarantee on the product unless you buy both.

I actually woke up with a small but clearly noticeable pain in my back every morning for a couple months. I intended to flip the mattress over, so I was sleeping on a different part of it, but did't get around to it. I noticed two weeks ago, months later, that my back never hurts in the morning anymore, and it hasn't for months I think. I can't remember the last time.

I'm sure I would dislike memory foam and all the others advertised on TV. I've always been happy for decades with an innerspring mattress and I still am.

And aiui most people put a mattress cover at least, if ont a mattress pad, on their mattress all the time, raither than put sheets down directly on the mattress. So I'd buy the pad and I'm still not happy, I'd use the pad on the new mattress.

Mattresses used to come in only one thickness (not counting sofa beds and summer camp, and maybe flophouses.) but now I think there are at least 3**. I recently looked at a mattress pad online that said it came in size for a 14" thick mattress. That strikes me as ridiculous since the earlier, ?six? inches seemed just fine. But be sure to buy a pad designed for your thickness or mulitple thicknesses.

**I dind't know this when I got my new mattress, and the headboard shelf I had made for my bed was now almost 2" too low, and the TV table on the other side of the bed was too low also 2", I couldnt' see the whole screen anymore. If I'd seen this coming, I wouldn't have bought the mattress I raised both up but I'm not pleased with the result.

Whatever you do, don't get a vinyl pr plastic cover if indeed they sell mattresses like that.

Reply to
micky

A mattress pad adds no support, all it does is help keep your mattress clean. Bite the bullet and get a new mattress and see if them hauling away your old mattress is part of the deal.

Reply to
ItsJoanNotJoann

You may be surprised. I was unsure of memory foam but have never slept better. I'm in bed right now with the head up and feet slightly up and very comfortable watching TV. I spend about a third of my life in bed so I;, not going to cheap out, I want what suites me best.

Reply to
Ed Pawlowski

By worn do you mean frayed, etc. That's how I took it. A cover will cover all that.

Or do you mean sagging springs?.

You'll have to take apart the bedding somewhat even for a pad or cover. Or when you change the sheets! But they are amazingly expensive.

A friend of a friend went last Sunday a week into a rehab home, not for drugs but after some hospital stay. The mattress was very firm and covered in plastic, sort of a grainy surface, so maybe not as hot and uncomfortable as totally flat plastic would have been . Anyhow she didn't like it and the friend we share sent me out there with two different pads and two different covers. Someone on the staff stripped the bed and I was putting the pad and cover on until they said they'd do it. She said she was happy but hadn't actually lay down yet.

One pad was a narrow blue closed foam pad that did not easily compress much thinner than it was. The other was a white/yellow foam one with an array of foam mountains. conical with rounded tops, but it was so soft I could squeeze it down to a quarter inch with little effort. At the time the time I thought the blue one was better for her, and I still think so except it's even narrower than the bed. So now I'm not sure.

Some of them used the term "topper" that I had never heard before.

Reply to
micky

Yeah, good idea.

Like when your 15 year old car with 210,000 miles on the odometer is falling apart, nothing like a nice Earl Scheib paint job and slick new seat covers to make everything right again. Nitwit.

Reply to
Wade Garrett

ItsJoanNotJoann posted for all of us...

+1 What I was going to post. FYI there are more models of mattress than cars, get one with a trial period. They are NOT like they used to be.
Reply to
Tekkie®

i sleep so much better now with the memory foam. it may take a few weeks to get used to it.

they are warmer to sleep on in the summer than you might expect. i don't mind being warmer.

for $100 it was a great buy.

songbird

Reply to
songbird

HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.