Are BFCM appliance sales actually deals, or just marketing? Appliance AMA while I remodel

Nov 22, 2026 Last reply: 6 hours ago 6 Replies
Saved reading

First reply

GraniteFarmer

I've leaned on your videos a few times when trying to pick between washers, so glad to see you posting again even with the remodel eating your time. Turning an old Big Lots into an appliance store sounds like a serious project, I can see why output slowed down. On your…

Read the full reply

Figure I'd do one of these again since it's been a while. I run a fairly large appliance channel on YouTube, and right now I'm mid-remodel on an old Big Lots building for my store, so my video output has been crawling lately. Bad timing with BFCM so close, but that's how it goes. Quick context on me: before appliances I worked as a data analyst, so this year I sank a lot of hours into building out appliance databases. Mostly trying to sort what's genuinely a sale from what's just the regular price wearing a costume, and what's a good machine versus a bad one. I've also put togehter some new package and model comparison tools that are rolling into videos soon. I can provide a photo or link to verify who I am if anyone wants it, since identity stuff on these threads sometimes gets questioned. So while I juggle the remodel and video work, ask me anything appliance related. And I'm genuinely curious where people land on this: do you all think the big holiday appliance sales are real savings, or mostly marketing dressed up as discounts? I've got my own take from the data side, but I want to hear what buyers here actually think.


I've leaned on your videos a few times when trying to pick between washers, so glad to see you posting again even with the remodel eating your time. Turning an old Big Lots into an appliance store sounds like a serious project, I can see why output slowed down.

On your question, my take from buying during the last couple of holiday seasons is that some of it is real and some of it is dressed up. The doorbuster deals on the heavily advertised models look impressive until you check the model number and realize it's a near-clone made just for the sale. The packages and bundles tend to be where I've seen honest savings, especially when I actually needed a matching set anyway. What I'd love is exactly what you describe with the databases, something that shows me what a model sold for in October versus what it's tagged at during BFCM. That's the piece I can never verify on my own, and I end up guessing whether to wait or buy. The comparison tools sound useful too, since spec sheets are deliberately hard to line up side by side.

One thing I'm curious about: with your data background, did you find certain brands run fake discounts more than others, or is it pretty spread across the board? I have my suspicions about a couple of them but no way to prove it.

I have to push back a bit on the idea that it's a mixed bag. From my side, I treat the big holiday appliance sales as marketing first and savings second, and your database project sounds like exactly the kind of thing that would prove me right or wrong. Before I got burned once on a 'doorbuster' fridge price that turned out to be the same as it was in October, I used to assume the ads meant something. Now I pretty much ignore the holiday framing entirely. If I'm shopping for a washer or a range, I watch the price for a few weeks like you apparently do with your data, and I buy when the number actually drops, whatever the calendar says. The BFCM stuff feels designed to make people buy faster, not cheaper.

The one thing I'm genuinely curious about with your tools is whether the packages are where the real deals hide, or if those are just bundles of slow-moving models pushed out the door with a holiday bow on them. Either way, having someone sort regular price from costume price is more useful than another ad telling me everything is 40 percent off. Did your data surprise you at all when you first ran it, or did it confirm what you already suspected?

Back when I started shopping for these things you walked into the local dealer, asked the price, and haggled. Nobody pretended the tag was a deal, it was just a number you negotiated down. Half the trickery these days comes from everything being published, so they can dress up a tag price as a sale. That said, your videos and site have saved me more than once when I was stuck between models, so the database work is welcome. Question for you though, are those package comparison tools going to be free to use, or are they baked into the videos only?

This is all kinda over my head since I just bought a fridge once and picked whatever was on the floor, but the database thing sounds cool. Like you actually went back and checked what stuff cost before the holiday ads hit? That seems way smarter than just trusting the big red sale tag.

One thing I wanted to ask about your remodel, is the store going to have stuff people can see running, like actual working machines on display? Every place near me just has boxes stacked up and you buy blind.

Curious how you're handling the price history side of those databases. Like, are you tracking what models actually sold for before the holiday ads roll out, or just what the retailers list? Seems like the listed price and the real checkout price don't always match once rebates and mail-in stuff get stacked on. If your tools can capture that gap it'd be huge for deciding whether to wait or just buy. Also hope the remodel doesn't eat your whole BFCM season, that's rough timing with video output already crawling.

Same here on the doorbuster thing. I remember standing in a store a couple years back staring at a washer tagged way down and feeling good about it, until I noticed the model number had extra letters tacked on and I couldn't even find it on the brand's own site. That kind of killed my trust in the big ads, so the bundle route makes sense to me too. My question for you is sort of the flip side of what someone asked: when a model does turn out to be a sale-only near clone, is it generally a worse machine or just a slightly different one?

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required