Anyone use either the Oneida Portable or the JDS 2hp Cyclone?

[Toller]

I am looking for a cyclone that will fit under my 90" ceiling and handle a single machine connected through a 4" hose. Oneida recommends their portable; they say that when choked by the 4" hose it will work just as well as the larger units. It is $1100. I like the small foot print, as my shop is very small, but think it is a bit pricy for the limited capacity. (and I have to drive 60 miles to pick it up at the factory to save the freight...) JDS recommends their 2hp for $950. It is both cheaper than the Oneida and more powerful, but takes up significantly more space.

Anything good or bad to say about either unit? The sale prices end this week, so I have to make a decision fast.

[greatviewcsc]

[digitect]

Why not ClearVue's Mini CV1400 Cyclone:

$945 + ~$90 for filter and includes shipping. 800 CFM through 4" pipe,

1100 through 6".

[Toller]

I am glad you brought it up; I didn't want to muddy the water with too many choices. I read about the Clearvue, and am a bit concerned with all the parts put together there was lots of places for air leaks, a 5hp motor is pretty heavy to be hanging from my wall, and I am not sold on the idea of plastic. Any thoughts on that would be appreciated.

Also, does the $945 cover EVERYTHING other than the filters? Do you use one filter or two? Nether of those is clear from their description.

[Leuf]

He does address this on the FAQ page.

It doens't include the two filters, trash can, or electrical switch or relay. I recommend taking a look through the installation instructions.

-Leuf