Split threads

May 02, 2013 6 Replies

Any idea why yesterday we saw so many threads appearing as multiple short threads - or individual posts - instead of nicely threaded as usual? Sure we get the odd one from time to time, but rarely lots.



Current release Thunderbird, using Berlin server here.



Apologies to anyone expecting nut-splitter thread...


Well did the thread originally start with TOT: by any chance. We proved a while back that most Microsoft news reading software struggles with these subject lines and can often take out the TOT: completely.

Brian

Thunderbird doesn't split a thread just because the subject changes, it goes by the references in headers. Usually thread splitting is caused by web based usenet interfaces such as google groups.

Proper software doesn't thread on the Subject: header line but on the References: one which contains all the Message-ID's of all the messages in the thread.

The normal way threads get broken is by postings from Google Groups.

Well a lot of them were subject "Unknown blade" by various posters. But I think there were some others like "Socket set".

"Unknown Blade" threaded perfectly here in both Demon/Turnpike and Eternal September/Pan.

I think it might be to do with my killfile and the member of it. :-)

(I think that funny things happen depending on order of arrival, killfile rule(s), etc.)

Apologies for raising the issue.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required