attn: news.individual.net users

Feb 03, 2019 Last reply: 7 years ago 10 Replies

In particular one using a gmail addy ...



WTF can't I reply to your posts ? It's only you - something somewhere is putting a CR/LF in the "References" header field which is causing either ES, or PAN to throw a wobbly and refuse to post.



Annoyingly it doesn't seem to trip an error, so I type a response, just to see it disappear ?



I have examples of the malformed (?) headers and can post if it helps.


Not me then

Looking at my own postingsl I don't see any incorrectly wrapped headers (I do see a correct continuation header)

You might need to ...

But you've obfuscated the header you claim is mangled, so we can't see whether you, or your reader mangled it, or if it looks good

Anyway, assuming you were trying to reply to Brian's reply to Tim Downie?

The references: header is not mangled as far as I can see, it seems your client is wrapping it at the hyphen

Message-ID: <q310gk$dva$ snipped-for-privacy@dont-email.me References: snipped-for-privacy@news.individual.net>

Reply-To: "Brian Gaff" snipped-for-privacy@blueyonder.co.uk>

again, there's a LF in the references field ...

30 years ago I would have just modified the code for PAN, but given USENET is slowly fading, it would be "like fitting wheels to a tomato" :)

Everything's public here ...

which Pan has put there, the LF before 1101416589 is ok, because the line begins with whitespace, but the LF before gmail is not ok, pan seems to have inserted it thinking it needs to wrap the hyphenated "downie-gmail"

The original headers in Tim's message are fine

Lines: 12 Message-ID: snipped-for-privacy@news.individual.net>

Mime-Version: 1.0

Aha ...

PAN not understand the RFC for email addys I can easily believe. I bet some numpty has rolled their own in the code...

I wonder if I can now set up something to test and prove it

Many thanks

Yes seen this as well though not actually looked into why, just tend to ignore it and move on and delete it from my outbox. Brian

I think I found es would not always post those, but sometimeas ao and sometimes albersani would but then if you use the latter it only accepts one newsgroup and if there are more needs a follups to in the header to post. Brian

Maybe Andy has hit on something and it's hyphenated (gmail ?) addresses ?

If I can be bothered, I'll set up some to test ... I wonder if the test usenet groups are still around ?

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required