Should I replace the whole door frame or just the door itself?

Nov 10, 2026 Last reply: 1 week ago 4 Replies
Saved reading

First reply

rob.grant

Your buddy's plan works when the frame is solid and the slab is the only problem. Yours isn't that situation. Soft spots at the bottom mean water has been sitting in there a while, and that water doesn't stay in the door. It wicks into the jamb legs and the threshold. Pull the…

Read the full reply

Our back door is shot. It sticks every time it rains, the bottom corner has soft spots, and I can see daylight around one edge in winter. A buddy of mine says I can just buy a new slab and hang it on the existing frame, which sounds way cheaper and easier. But then the guy at the lumberyard told me once the bottom of a door gets soft, the frame and threshold are ussually not far behind. He's pushing me toward a prehung unit, frame and all. That sounds like a way bigger job. Do I need to pull off the interior trim? Will the new frame even match the opening, since this house is from the 70s and nothing in it is square?



I'm reasonably handy with a circular saw and a level but I've never done a door from scratch. Is slab replacement something a first-timer can pull off, or am I signing up for a weekend of misery and a drafty door? Also, does it change anything that this door is covered by a small porch and doesn't get direct weather?


Your buddy's plan works when the frame is solid and the slab is the only problem. Yours isn't that situation. Soft spots at the bottom mean water has been sitting in there a while, and that water doesn't stay in the door. It wicks into the jamb legs and the threshold. Pull the exterior casing off one side and I'd bet money you find punky wood behind it. A new slab hung in a rotten frame just gives the rot a fresh meal. The sticking and the daylight are both frame problems too. Sticking after rain means the frame itself is swelling, and daylight around one edge means it's twisted or out of square. Swapping slabs fixes neither. So yeah, the lumberyard guy is right, go prehung.

As for the job itself, it's very doable for a first timer, but give yourself a full weekend and have a plan B for the night if the weather turns. You do not have to rip off the interior trim. The trick is to cut the nail shanks between the old frame and the rough framing with a recip saw, pull the old unit, and slide the new one in behind the casing. Sometimes you need to trim the drywall returns a hair, but usually the new frame tucks right in and you reuse the casing. Worst case you replace the interior casing, which is cheap and way easier than it looks. The 70s house thing is actualy less of a problem than you'd think. Prehung units get shimmed to plumb and level independent of the rough opening, so a wonky opening matters less than you'd expect. Bring a good level, a pile of composite shims, and plenty of exterior caulk and low-expansion foam. Set the threshold on a bead of caulk and flash the top of the opening before the new frame goes in. That last part is what keeps you from doing this again in ten years. The porch helps but doesn't save you. Wind-driven rain and snow melt still blow under a covered door, and your soft bottom corner is proof. Get fiberglass, spend real money on the hinges and the sill, and take your time shimming. That's the whole job.

This actually clears up a lot for me because I have the same kind of door situation going on. One thing I keep getting stuck on when I look at these at the store, there seem to be diffrent thicknesses and widths and I have no clue which one mine is. When I go to order the whole unit, do I measure the opening in the wall itself or just copy whatever the old door is?

On the measuring question, don't just copy the old door, mine was swollen a half inch when I measured it and I woud've ordered wrong. Pull the interior trim off one side if you can and measure the rough framing, width at top, middle and bottom, plus the height to the subfloor. The stud-to-stud number is what the store wants. If you can't get at the framing, measure the slab itself on a dry day and tell them the door size, they'll spec the unit from that. Measure twice on a day it hasn't rained, learned that the hard way.

Did a prehung in my old place a few years back and the thing that got me wasn't the door at all, it was what was hiding under the old threshold. Pulled it out and the subfloor at the corner was mush, so I was patching that before the new unit could go in. Check that spot early so you're not surprised halfway thru the job. Also hang onto the old slab til the new one's in, it's handy for blocking the hole overnight if you don't finish in one day.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required