I have checked Grizzly web site and I see that they are selling a 2HP
canister dust collector that looks like the one that JET introduced to
market not so long ago. The interesting espects are:
- It is rated to filter down to 1-micron (vs 2-micron in JET).
- Its filter is made from spun bonded polyester instead of paper
(JET's is made from paper, right?) According to Bill's Cyclone web
site, spun bonded polyester is preferred because it is more durable.
Seem like it is a very good choice if someone cannot use a cyclone
(may be "vertically challenged", not enough budget, ...etc). I have a
couple questions though:
- It can filter dusts down to 1-micron. This is good. But I am under
the impression that we should filter the dust down to 0.5-micron. How
big a difference between these two filtration rates in term of health
and cleanliness anyway?
- JET came up with a 2-micron canister last year, and Grizzly came up
with a 1-micron canister this year. Should I expect to see a canister
that can handle 0.5-micron dusts next year (as in 2004)? Anyone knows
any information about this trend?
- What's that 1-micron filtration rate really mean anyway? Does this
mean it can filter down to 1-micron but only at 75% efficiency? If
this is the case, it may be able to filter down to 2-micron at 99%
efficiency, and this may mean that it should have been rated as
2-micron after all, instead of the "marketing friendly" 1-micron
rating. This is just a guess. I would like to see if someone knows
something about this rating.
- Is the filter "certified" as having that filtration rating? Or is
it just something the vendor comes up with?
- Has anyone used it? How does it work so far?
By the way, I am not likely to buy that Grizzly dusts collector
because it needs 220 volt that I don't have. I am only interested in
filtration rate of its filter.
it the situation of these dc's I can see the paper wearing out. any find dust
and shavings can spin back up into the fitter. that will wear it out.
it's better then a bag for sure.
yes .5 is better. but if you don't make a lot of fine sawdust it may be ok.
I have not checked one of the new dc's out but if it has good airflow and you
keep the fitters clean it will filter the fine sawdust too. the better the
airflow the more sawdust the filter will filter.
who knows. lets hope grizzly is telling the truth.
with these filters I doubt we will ever know. my cyclone filters are rated.
Knight-Toolworks & Custom Planes
Custom made wooden planes at reasonable prices
Ask Grizzly what percentage of 1 micron particles are filtered out and
post their answer. I asked Jet the same question about their "2 micron"
cannister filter and the answer was "it filters down to 2 microns". In
other words if they have real filter specs they aren't saying. Makes
me suspicious. Even 3M disposable furnace filters have more detailed
specs. Another question related to the design of these fiters is
whether the mechanical flexing of the filter pleats needed to remove
accumulated dust cake from the filter to keep its flow decent affects
the filtration specs? Do they change over time?
I took your advice, and emailed Grizzly about the efficiency rating of
the filter in their cannister dust collector. I will post their answer
(if any) when I get something back from them.
I have a feeling that I may get the similar answer as what you got
from JET. I will not be surprised if that filter actually capture much
less than 99% of dusts that are 1-micron small. Oh well...
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.