Canada wins NAFTA ruling on softwood lumber

Excerpt:

"The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) review panel rejected claims by Washington that its lumber producers had suffered damage as a result of Canadian imports.

The panel ordered the US International Trade Commission to reverse its determination on the lumber imports, which resulted in the laying of 19 percent countervailing duties on Canadian wood, within 10 days."

Reply to
Dave Balderstone
Loading thread data ...

  1. the news reports here indicate its a 27% duty and
  2. The US can appeal, dragging this out (it seems) interminally..

Its already been going on 2 years..it seems they'll just keep it up til they get the result they want, meanwhile, the extra overhead is passed on to who ? The US consumer..

Reply to
Rudy

Cooperation with the ICBM may do it for bush, I think!

Reply to
f/256

Tell you what. US will export some environmentalists, if you'll take 'em duty free, and nobody will harvest wood within ten years....

Reply to
George

Huh?

Reply to
Bob Schmall

A common debating tactic with both conservatives and liberals in the United States is to assume that the most radical positions of the opposite side represent the views of every opponent. For example, "those loony tree huggers want to ban all logging." In fact the vast majority of conservationists call for RESPONSIBLE cutting and reforestration rather than the clearcutting that was the industry norm a few years ago. Even the lumber industry has bought into that for its own long-term good. In fact, shipping a few conservationists to Canada would be a benefit for its industry and a loss to ours.

Bob

Reply to
Bob Schmall

We've got enough up here, tenjewberrymush.

Reply to
Dave Balderstone

And the Canadian millworkers also suffer too. This all sucks. The NAFTA panel has told the US Govt to stop fighting the rulings.

Today's Globe and Mail Report on Business reports that the WTO has "given Canada the go-ahead to slap trade sanctions on the U.S., which could amount to billions of dollars if Washington hands the more than $2.7-billion (U.S.) in softwood levies collected from Canadian timber over to American forest companies."

Reply to
Daniel

You're right. However, the problem with many current "reforestation" efforts is the same problem with tomatoes in the grocery store ... product is genetically designed for the benefit of the corporation, not the consumer.

Then again, a tasteless red biomass with soft seeds is marginally better in a salad than nothing for those who never experienced the difference .... and add a corollary for a tubafour while you're at it.

Reply to
Swingman

And force-grown. It's still better than a depressing bald spot in what once was a forest.

Sure: Corollary: never include reforested wood in your salad.

Are you saying you don't like square tomatoes that ship well? You oughta see the hardwood peaches we get up here in Wisconsin.

No, you shouldn't

Bob

Reply to
Bob Schmall

I got a kick out of the clear-cut practice/subterfuge/token-to-the-environmentalist (however you want to view it) in Southern Arkansas where the land is flatter ... they leave strips along the roads so you can't see the clear-cut and, as you're driving through, you'd swear there wasn't a logging company for miles.

Probably what the suits tritely refer to as a "win-win" ... but, of course, they win more.

Along those same lines, I am looking for some "heirloom" tomato seeds for next year ... anyone know of a good source for old stock, genetically unaltered, tomato?

Reply to
Swingman

Or slowing down the flow of Canadian oil and gas into the US.

Reply to
mp

Got any wood-frame (Obww) farmer's tomato stands in your area? We're just wrapping up the second coldest summer on record, and I finally, today, the First of September, found ripe tomatoes at the local stand. Sheesh.

Bob

Reply to
Bob Schmall

C'mon, as a cheesehead you should know better. You _can't_ grow seedling conifers under mature, and if you thin them enough to get light to the ground, the big ones blow over. That's why they're clear-cut. Fire used to take care of the problem by clearing areas - to the ground - which it sweetened with ashes enough for new growth. Anyone with sense can see that the only difference between that and clear-cutting, then spreading lime to sweeten the acid soil, is that you get to use the wood.

I'm next door, and we're harvesting at touch less than half the rate of growth, and then only because of private landowners. The state and national forests are harvested at around a third and slowing, because of agitation for roadless initiatives and wilderness set-asides, not to mention my favorite, the "wild and scenic rivers " initiative which would have locked up a bit over twenty on my place. Public hearings were held 400 miles away, by a group of government officials and environmentalists. Landowners were allowed up to three minutes to address this unbiased group, even though they were the ones who would bear the taking. Fortunately the initiator was defeated in his downstate district, though not over a measure which was popular among all those who would not have been affected.

Oh yes, the construction lumber mill up the road, which sawed softwood equal in every way to the Canadian, went under recently because it couldn't get a guaranteed supply.

Reply to
George

Burpee has an heirloom line of seeds that I've been quite happy with over the years. Good germination, great catalog.

Dave Hinz

Reply to
Dave Hinz

We do have an abundance of farmer's produce markets and stands down here in Texas, but most of the tomatoes are still of the hybrid variety that are "engineered" more for shelf life than taste. I've been growing my own for a while, on the front porch in an "earth box", but the varieties available as seedlings are the same, basically tasteless, hybrids that you get at the markets.

Taste being one of the last things to go, and wanting to take full advantage of that fact, it is apparent that if I want to taste a real tomato again, like the one's we had as kids on the farm, I am going to have to go to extraordinary measures to do so. Next year I want to plant some old heirloom seeds, in a flat like we used to do, then transplant to the "earth box", and see if that doesn't improve things.

I've got a shaker with a combination of salt and pepper in it out in the shop (Obww), and always keep a couple of tomatoes in the shop fridge ... keeps your hand steady for those taper jig cuts. :)

Reply to
Swingman

Once again, a non-scientist confuses "weather" with "climate".

Reply to
Dave Hinz

So don't buy seedlings. It's easy to start your own indoors from seeds, and there's lots of good varieties available from some of the lesser-known seed houses. We get most of ours from

formatting link
Many of the "heirloom" varieties produce wrinkled or mis-shapen fruit which don't go over well in commercial markets, but the taste can't be beat.

Reply to
Roy Smith

And once again, someone who has absolutely no knowledge of the actual facts jumps to an erroneous conclusion.

Reply to
Swingman

As I said, I am looking for "seeds" ... thanks for the link.

Reply to
Swingman

HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.