OT Insurance and banks

Jun 08, 2014 59 Replies
Saved reading
Jump to replies (59)

Saga sent me a renewal quote for house/buildings insurance this week and suggested in the letter that I didn't have to look around for alternatives as they were always the cheapest.


15 minutes of looking around on the Web has given me like for like quotes that are up to 40% cheaper. One of the cheaper quotes is better value with lower excesses.

Both Barclay (who have taken over ING UK accounts) and RBS have sent letters this week saying that the rates on their savings accounts have fallen to virtually nothing and both imply that I should f*ck off as they no longer want any saving business. Luckily I moved my money out from both sets of accounts around this time last year.


In article , alan writes

If that truly is the case then complain to the ASA and they will stop them making that false claim in the future. They cover claims in any kind of medium presented to you and IME are one of the more useful regulators:

formatting link

Yes, it seemed that Barclays couldn't wait to get rid of me and my legacy ING accounts.

I wonder what they got out of the ING deal? Mortgages probably.

That is a good lie. Unfortunately many aged folk are far too trusting and follow their advice thinking that SAGA really acts *for* old people. It is a business like many others that preys on the elderly.

50% less is not unusual try a bit harder.

Swinton were surprisingly competitive on home insurance last time I looked nad you lose nothing by asking for a quote.

Not quite. They still want the money deposited from the savings business but they only want to pay 0.1% on it they can get away with it 0.0% interest and will trap the unwary in dormant zombie accounts.

Halifax have a particularly good pair with deliberately confusing names:

Ripoff Saver interest rate 1.70% Saver Ripoff interest rate 0.10% (whopping 0.18% on £100k+)

Of course they spell "Ripoff" as "Reward".

You have to look danmed hard on their website to find the interest rate details for all the legacy accounts that elderly folk have what remains of their life savings languishing in.

formatting link

I hate to think what their "Punish Saver" account looked like but on second thoughts I guess they were called "Endowment Mortgages".

I dumped RBS (because their mainframe was crashing on more than one occasion).

Moved to Nationwide - seems they have some of the better savings accounts too.

Hmm I also find it a bit annoying that soon after you put your money into one of these accounts, they change the rules so you only get top interest if you have over a certain amount in it. Itt somehow feels like if the rest of the worlds products worked like this people would come along at night and cut off part of your house and sell it to somebody else!

Brian

And to get really "good" rates (comparatively) like 2.5% you have to run accounts like a "regular saver" which means drip feeding it every month with the permitted amount.

I remember when National Savings gave over 10% interest. Then again inflation was 20% or worse!

+1 for Swinton. I started using them when I had an odd-ball car to insure and they found a suitable insurer. That, of course was back in the days when I had a car. The good thing from my POV is being able to walk into an office and talk face to face with someone who knows what they are about.

Nick

On 08 Jun 2014, Martin Brown grunted:

Yes I once had house insurance with them (their year one being the best quote around). I dropped the ball on renewal, not realising that they had set up an annual direct debit, and ended up paying about 40% more for year

  1. The following year, when I did change company, the premium was back to the same as Saga year 1.
+1. I always warn off my mum from them.

If you are prepared to put the work in and pro-actively manage your savings (which ATM I am not) you can get reasonable returns from running multiple current accounts:

formatting link

Nick

That, of course, is obvious nonsense.

So give Saga the choice: they can either provide you with a quote that's cheaper than that, like for like, or they can concede that they're not to be trusted.

FWIW, Saga were way the cheapest for contents insurance a couple of years ago, and have remained so, especially given that we've had a subsidence claim (not for contents) and the vast majority of insurers won't even touch contents once that's happened. Saga said "That's silly - what's subsidence got to do with contents?" and even put that in writing. Nonetheless, I am well aware that all insurers rely on loyalty to bump up premiums and keep a weather eye on it.

(In other surprises, Direct Line remained cheapest for the third year in row on my Disco, after the NFU hugely hiked its premiums & prompted me to move.)

And a sensible amount cheaper like at least 10% not price match or a quid or two less.

Can't decided if this comes under the ASA or not. If the letter really does say "always cheaper" with no small print qualifying it then it is seriosuly misleading and needs to be stopped. After all Saga target the elderly, who are generally rather more trusting than other groups and may well not have the abilty to quickly jump onto the nest to verify the claim of "always cheapest".

I have a vague feeling that new legislation has appeared that forces the banks etc to tell customers if the accounts they hold are not good value compared to other accounts from the same bank. Though I expect there is quite a large hysteresis.

Saga did much the same to me, whilst offering an increase of ~50%!

I went to Age UK at just under Saga's price for the first year; since then (3 renewals), Age UK's price has drifted up and down(!) by about 1 - 2%.

Saga is just a profiteering business ripping off old folk, IMO.

Yes - I've seen that too. I think running them could be devolved to some standing orders but the effort in setting them up is not trivial!

An insurance company? Trusted? Tee-hee.

-1 for Swinton - they play the same silly games. They will also email you on a daily basis asking if you want extra insurance for something else.

I was insured with them for a year. The renewal quote comes and it's substantially more than the previous year. The covering letter said (paraphase) "if you don't contact us we will automatically renew your insurance so that you are not left without cover."

I looked around and took cover from another company and then phoned them to be told that they wouldn't have automatically renewed the policy and they would have matched any quote that I received. I politely told them that if they had offered a competitive quote in the first place I would have would have bothered shopping around.

In message , Huge writes

snip

Umm.. My vehicles have been insured with NFU for two generations:-)

For the last 3 years I have had serious concerns about their premium for my Hilux, currently doing about 800 miles/annum. Lots of correspondence but no reduction.

I think their problem is their light goods insurance includes comprehensive cover on towing. There have been a number of instances where 4/4s towing cattle trailers have jacknifed/overturned on dual carriageways with expensive consequences for their insurers.

Currently, the Hilux is with Tesco who only offer 3rd. party on towed trailers.

If I have to look around and find a cheaper (sensible like for like) I will always change. By ringing them up I would be just playing into their hands and they will continue with the same tricks. Business may only stop if the churn rate increases.

Start of thinking that they are not to be trusted and you will not go far wrong. ALL financial institutions/insurance companies have a track record of screwing loyal custom.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required