...As far as I can tell most USB webcams are *hard wired* so that data cannot be streamed without the light being on...
I believe mine certainly is. (Logitech C170)
I do note that linux never lights it up unless I am using it
Didn't find your answer? Ask the community — no account required.
A
Andy Burns
Perhaps you are putting too much faith in the manufacturer, I would suspect the I/O port driving the LED is independent from reading data from the image sensor, so you're at the mercy of the USB driver ...
J
John R Walliker
My Dell notebook PC runs linux Mint and only lights up the LED when the camera is active. However, there is no need to trust the software as it has a mechanical shutter over the camera lens.
John
P
Paul
Just put tape over it. OK ? :-)
formatting link
Paul
T
The Natural Philosopher
I can't see that that makes any sense.
There is only one 'I/O port' and that is the USB socket Which is serial data.
The LED is simply wired across the power supply that drives the camera: if the camera is on so is the LED.
Teh sole purpose of the LED is security: there is no reason to make it 'independent'
T
The Natural Philosopher
I see a vaguely worded threat from a company selling security. They can f*ck off as well. There is no way to 'reflash' a USB webcam. at least not mine
A
Andy Burns
I'm talking about I/O from the PoV of the µP inside the webcam.
There's also very likely an extra USB "endpoint" within the webcam, hidden until some sequence of events, but once enabled it allows re-flashing the firmware, or running in a test mode.
I doubt it, it will be controlled by firmware, otherwise every time you "turned off" the webcam, you'd have to unplug and re-plug it to start using tgw camera again.
For a genuine manufacturer, yes, you'd hope there was a direct link, but surely you can see how a less scrupulous (or diligent) manufacturer could allow the LED to provide the *illusion* of security?
T
The Natural Philosopher
There are no firmware upgrades available for that model nor any way to implement them
The whole camera is 'controlled by firmware' but my point is that the firmware switches the camera and microphone on , puts power to the modules and lights the LED which is running off the same power rails that the camera and mic are.
Armchair security experts are always finding edge cases where there
*might be* an issue as are firms selling their own scam security software.
The world is full of bullshit and 'could's', a point used by those proselytising for climate change using the bogus 'precautionary' principle which means that all risk no matter how impossible is to be avoided at all costs, so no one should ever be allowed to drive a car, won a chain saw, eat meat, own a carving knife etc. etc.
A
Andy Burns
And you know all of this, how?
A
Andy Burns
"Logitech Webcam C170
formatting link
› 360024784413-Webcam-C170 Firmware Update Tool is no longer supported or maintained by Logitech."
So there is a firmware mechanism ...
T
The Natural Philosopher
Because I looked at the manufactures data
Because I am an electronics/software engineer and I know 'how stuff works'.
Because others asked the question before.
Because that is the cheapest lowest component count way to do it
T
The Natural Philosopher
Doesn't exist on that site
No. There is not
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required
Report Content
You are reporting this content to the moderators. They will look at it
ASAP.