Good smoke detector?

Oct 26, 2012 78 Replies

Looking for opinions on which smoke detector to buy.



Mains powered sounds like a good idea, saves on battery cost.



Interlinked would be nice as one will be in an outbuilding.



I want a decent make, one that will not f*ck up like the cheap ones do. I've got a couple of cheap ones just now and they keep going off for no reason. No dust in them or anything. They also run the battery flat in a matter of months. They're optical. Is radiation better?


Don't tit about with battery powered ones, use mains interlinked ones with (rechargeable) battery backup.

Grade D as a minimum:

formatting link

advice, I didn't know they did that.

But... which make? Are they all the same? Are some s**te?

advice, I didn't know they did that.

I use Kidde kit, good stuff with a decent 6 year warranty.

Available from TLC

formatting link

advice, I didn't know they did that.

formatting link
that's very expensive. I've found some cheaper ones that say "CE, BSI, SAI Global approved, comply with EN14604, AS3786 and UL217 standard". Does that mean anything?

IMHO Scotty should not bother with any smoke detectors - fingers crossed etc.

Wouldn't it make more sense to get a bad smoke detector? That's what is going to get you...

Absolutely, that's his usual MO. Someone beam him up. He has a degree, you know.

(usually, he asks a question, gets a few replies then proceeds to tell the respondents why they're wankers).

formatting link
>Ok, that's very expensive.

You really think that ukp 27 is very expensive for reliable kit that is designed to save your life? It may possibly be worth you saving up for it.

-- rbel

It's not to save my life. It's to save my property from fire damage los= ses. I am not scared of fire.

And it's =A381, I need three.

formatting link
>>>Ok, that's very expensive.

Please don't encourage him.

formatting link
>>>>>>>>> Ok, that's very expensive.

That is possibly one the dumbest things I have heard you say (which is saying something).

Still cheap. Pay the money get over it. They last 10 years so that is £8/year.

formatting link
>>>>>>>>

Sadly, the lootenant is a complete f****it even though he posseses a degree (a scan of which he posted). LMFAO. What a prick, we actually live amongst these people. Ya hafta laugh.

What in - medieval media studies?

I'd prefer living amongst a 1000 clones of him rather than all the chavs in Hastings. At least he's mostly harmless.

formatting link
>>

Earlier you said you wanted a "decent make". When someone recommends a decent make (Kidde are) you complain about the price! You get what you pay for!

formatting link
>>>>>>>>>

That has to be a record for the most stupid remark ever.

Approx 2p a day.

Incidentally, I use Firex alarms. No problems here. I picked them mainly because I could get the useful pattresses from the same supplier. They use dry batteries for backup, but that's no great problem.

The radiation type use a radioactive source so no light to be on all the time, though eventually the source does die of course.

Brian

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required