I selling a relative's home and am wondering if I should pay to have a
45 yr old Kitchenaid dishwasher that won't start fixed, or replace it
with a brand new Bosch? The difference in cost is a few hundred
dollars. If the repair only adds 90 days or whatever to the life of the
Kitchenaid, does it make sense?
Why replace it now? New owner may be planning a color change or complete
remodel of kitchen. I would put a fixed dollar amount in the Realtor's
listing to be given to the new owner at closing for dishwasher changeout.
Bosch is probably the quietest dishwasher out there but isn't the easiest to
service and doesn't have a "hard food disposer" which is wanted by most
buyers. Bosch has a little cup that catches the hard stuff and relies on
hot water and time to dissolve most stuff caught in it.
best to do nothing and just note it is not working and offer an allowance.
As has been stated new owner may want a different color.
You could install a Bosch and have someone look at the house that does not
like Bosch and make it into a negative? Or they may never had heard of
Best to just let the buyer be aware and then you can negotiate the
replacement or an allowance.
It is kind of like carpet 99% of homes you look at have tan/beige carpet
because it is neutral. Everyone is afraid they will get a color someone else
will not like.
On 8 May 2005 21:37:13 -0700, ollie_w firstname.lastname@example.org wrote (with
FWIW - and assuming you mean 4 - 5 year old, I just had exactly the
same situation. I had a top of the line Kitchen Aid Dishwasher which
I had bought to replace a working 18 year old Kitchen Aid - big
mistake. The problem was that it got too hot. I called the dealer
from whom I bought the machine. He came out twice but could not fix
it. I called Kitchen Aid who just told me to call the dealer. They
were absolutely no help. In the meantime, I figured out that what was
probably broken was the high temperature thermostat. However, the
dealer walked off with the service literature which was in the bottom
of the machine. Again, Kitchen Aid refused to help.
I finally gave up in disgust. Today's Kitchen Aid is not like the old
one. I bought a new Bosch. The darn thing is so quiet, you have to
look carefully to determine if it's on. I'll never buy any Kitchen
Aid appliance again and nothing from the local dealer. I'll bet he
could care less.
OTOH, if it really is 45 years old, too bad. It was better made than
anything you can buy today, but I doubt you'll be able to get parts
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.