Hey thanks for the responses guys! Let me see if I can respond to each
Q: Is the switch upside down?
A: The switch is not upside down - the terminals are indeed on the
Q: Do I have two switches controlling the light?
A: No, I only have one switch controlling the light. I had a similar
style switch next to it (for a different light), that I swapped
switches with, to rule out the switch being bad.
Q: Am I confusing neutral with hot?
A: I don't think I am ... At the fixture, the neutral is white, and
the hot supply wire is orange. At the switch, the hot supply wire is
yellow, and the one going to the fixture is orange.
Q: What type of switch am I using? (pointed at Roger)
A: It's a single rocker switch; That is the only switch controlling