Sorted out the no-sheathing garage wall problem, sharing what I did

Nov 19, 2026 Last reply: 5 hours ago 3 Replies
Saved reading
Jump to replies (3)

Spent the last three weekends getting my drafty garage ready for winter and figured I'd post how it went in case anyone else has walls with just siding and no sheathing behind it. When I pulled a board off to check, it was literally just horizontal siding nailed straight to the studs, you coud see daylight through the gaps in a few spots. Instead of spraying anything directly onto the boards, I hung furring strips inside and ran batt insulation between them, then closed it up with plywood. That way the siding stays completly untouched on the outside, so if I ever need to swap a rotted board I just unscrew the plywood in that spot and go at it from inside.



Biggest surprise was how much air was moving through those gaps before I even got to the insulation part. I spent a whole Saturday caulking and foaming the seams around the door frame and where the walls meet the slab, and that alone made the space feel diferent.



Ran a space heater out there for a few hours last night to test it and it held heat way better than I expected. Still need to figure out the ceiling, but the walls are done and I'm calling that a win.


I did almost the same thing on my detached two-car garage about four years ago, except I went with rigid foam between the studs instead of batts. My walls were bare boards over open framing too, and cutting 2 inch foam to fit each bay was honestly easier than wrestling with fiberglass in that space. I taped the seams and it made the whole garage feel airtight in a way I didn't expect.

Agree that the air sealing was the bigger win. I found a big gap behind the trim where the wall met the roof edge, stuffed it and foamed over it, and the place stopped feeling like a wind tunnel that same night. For the ceiling, mine is open rafters and I did foam between them plus a continuous layer across the underside to cover the rafter faces. That continuous layer mattered more than I thought it whould, so don't skip it if you can spare the room.

One thing to check before you start up there is the overhead door itself. Mine had basicly no weatherstripping left, and a cheap seal kit plus a sweep along the bottom cut the drafts more than any extra insulation I added. A drafty door will eat everything you just did to the walls.

I took a lazier route on my place. Mine is an attached garage and the wall that shares the house is the only one I really cared about, so I just did dense packed cellulose in that one wall. Drilled holes through the drywall I'd already hung, blew it in with a rental machine from the home center, plugged the holes, done in an afternoon. The other three walls I left alone because I'm only out there working on the car a few hours at a time and the concrete slab holds enough warmth that it stays workable.

The ceiling is where I'd push you to spend your effort if you only do one more thing. Heat goes straight up and out, and my garage stayed cold til I blew insulation across the ceiling joists. I laid down some depth rulers so the guy could see how deep he was going and just told him to keep going until it looked like a foot of snow.

Also, if you're planning to run that space heater a lot, check what's on the circuit out there. Mine trips the breaker if the shop vac is plugged in at the same time, which I learned the hard way mid-project with a half sanded fender.

Watch what's in those stud bays before you screw furring strips down. I ran the same furring setup in my shop years ago and drove a screw right thru the run going to the garage door opener. Had to pull that strip back off and notch around it. Ten minutes with a flashlight and a phone camera up in each bay saves a headache later. For the ceiling, I never finished mine. Just insulated between the joists and left it open, and it made more difference than the walls did honestly. Heat goes up and mine was wide open to the rafters, so that may be most of what's left for you.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required