How do you clear out an attic full of old junk before blowing in new insulation?

Nov 10, 2026 Last reply: 1 week ago 3 Replies
Saved reading

Most relevant reply

Dan_Pewter

I did this exact job two summers ago and here's how it shook out. The big vacuum rigs you're seeing advertised are mostly for loose fill like cellulose or blown fiberglass. They'll eat old crusty batts too if the crew chops them up as they go, but chunks of plaster, shingle…

Read the full reply

So we finally got around to planning new insulation for the attic, and it turns out the last people who lived here basially used the space as a dumping ground. There's broken plaster chunks, old shingle scraps, bits of rotted wood, and what looks like decades of flattened fiberglass that's gone gray and crusty. None of it is doing anything for warmth, and I'm pretty sure the blown-in stuff won't sit right on top of all that mess anyway. My first thought was to just bag it by hand, but honestly the thought of crawling around pulling up dusty old batts that might have who knows what in them is not appealing. I've seen ads for those huge vacuum rigs some companies use, but I assume those are for loose fill, not for lumber scraps and plaster lumps mixed in. Does a service like that even take this kind of mixed debris, or is that a waste of money here? The access is one of those pull-down ladders, so anything I carry out has to come down through the hatch. That alone makes me think renting a shop vac and going bag by bag is going to take forever. Has anyone dealt with a cleanup job like this before doing insulation? Did you DIY it or hire it out, and was it worth the cost?


I did this exact job two summers ago and here's how it shook out. The big vacuum rigs you're seeing advertised are mostly for loose fill like cellulose or blown fiberglass. They'll eat old crusty batts too if the crew chops them up as they go, but chunks of plaster, shingle scraps, and rotted lumber will jam the hose or just plain not fit through it. So yeah, your instinct is right, that service alone won't clear out the heavy junk. What some companies do instead is an attic restoration package: a two or three person crew bags everything by hand up top, passes it down through the hatch, runs the vac for the fine dusty layer, and hauls it away. That's the version worth getting a quote on. For me it came out to a few hundred per hour but they cleared the whole attic in a day, which would've taken me two weekends solo.

If you go DIY, work top to bottom and in sections. Get the solid debris out first, shingles and wood and plaster, because you can grab that stuff with minimal dust. The gray flattened fiberglass goes last, and honestly that's the miserable part. A shop vac helps with the crumbs and dust left behind but you'll still be pulling up the bulk of it by hand into contractor bags. One trick that helped a lot: I set up a pulley system at the hatch so I could lower full bags down instead of carrying them down a ladder. Even a rope and a bucket for the small stuff saves a ton of trips.

Don't forget the second half of the job either. Full contractor bags are heavy and awkward, and depending on your local dump you may need to sort debris from regular trash or pay by weight. If you're renting a trailer or borrowing a truck, plan that out before you start so you're not staring at twenty bags in the garage with nowhere to take them. Also worth a quick call to your town or waste hauler, some do bulk pickup days that make the disposal part way easier.

We paid a junk removal outfit instead of an insulation company and it worked out fine. Two guys came up through the hatch with thier own bags and hauled everything off same day, rotted stuff and all. Cost more than doing it myself would've, but I didn't lose a weekend to it, so no regrets.

One thing I'd figure out before anyone blows new stuff in: what you're doing about air sealing up there. The dusty gray batts are ussually hiding gaps around wiring and the chase walls, and sealing those before the blow-in makes a way bigger difference than the extra inches of insulation. Ask whoever's quoting the job if they include it.

Agree with the junk removal route, that's what we did and I'd do it again. One thing I'd add: ask up front whether their quote includes the old insulation, because the first outfit I called quoted the junk fine but wanted extra once they saw the gray batts up there. The company we went with charged by volume in the truck, so I just had everything bagged and stacked near the hatch before they showed up and it went fast. Took them maybe two hours total including the lumpy stuff. Worth confirming that detail on the phone so the price doesn't change on you mid-job.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required