decision on 2 Payne units

If you're south of the Mason Dixon line go with the heat pump and stay away from Payne.

Payne hertz ?

Sir

You say stay away from Payne. any reason, the other units available in this area in the NE PA area would be ComfortMaker or I might be able to get York

Chet

What did the Manual J heat load/loss calculations come out for sizing the system?

Before you get too far, you need to *READ* the warranty sheets.... any equipment bought from the internet has *NO WARRANTY*.

Also be aware that no legitimate company will install any equipment that was not purchased through their company due to liability and warranty issues.

That being said.... your a cheap bastage... if you don't take anything else from this forum, remember this;

"The bitter taste of a poor quality installation will linger far longer than the initial sweetness of a low price."

If you're doing cooling only, I'd go with the one with the higher efficiency.

Don't know what brought your reply on so weird, I am not buying from the Internet, don't know what the J heat load loss is, the installer figured what the home required.

Sounds like the installer used a "rule of thumb" to size the system.... thats nothing but a guess.... and you gonna base this decission on a guess??....

That is what I had in mind also, I ask my installer what his opinion was,he would go with the heat pump because it was cheaper, I think I am going with the cooling only

Chet

actually my installer does work for the company I am a manager of. and I use him for our business's heating & cooling. I had 2 other estimates for my home last fall one guy suggested a 2 1/2 ton and the other offered either the 2 1/2 or 3 ton

Go with the York if you can afford it. Payne is Carrier's low end junk. Personally I prefer American Standard but if you cant get the good s*it in your area you're stuck with what ever.

So nobody has actually done the math to correctly size the system for your home..... Its not like going to Walmart and buying a toaster that plugs into the wall. *IF* the installer is doing his job right, he should be designing the system specifically for your homes needs. You are about to make a decission that your going to have to live with for the next 15 - 20 years..... Hire a professional, not the lowest bidder or somebody who "does it on the side".

Hmmm, As a consumer if I am having an installer do work on my HVAC needs I want him do the basics first. Manual J calculation to get at the system requirement. He has to look at duct system too. Installing either under/over sized system is economically bad thing and also it'll impact your comfort level. Payne is low end Carrier costing less. There is a reason it costs less. Like Armstrong is made by Lennox. I am familiar with Carrier and always stick with Carrier and good dependable(knowledge, training and experience) tech I have known for years. Do the right thing and enjoy the result for many years to come.