My plans are to specify a (Gas) Tankless Hot Water Heater in our new home
for my wife and myself. I'm thinking about actualy including two of them,
one for bathrooms and one for Kitchen and Laundry demands but not sure on
the total number to have yet.
I've looked at Takagi, Rinnai, Noritz, Paloma, Bosch, and Rheem. Like
everything else most familiarity with Tankless hot water heaters comes from
advertisements on the radio and TV and of those Rinnai seems to put the most
money in that area.
Of you who have a tankless hot water heater which ones are the most trouble
free and which would you recommend? Thanks, in advance, for your help and
Along with reading the info you will get in response to your current
question in this group, may I suggest you perform a Google Groups
search on the subject. This question has been discused in
alt.home.repair, alt.building.construction, misc.consumers.house,
misc.consumers.frugal-living and many other groups. There is a lot of
information from various sources available in these groups.
Go to http://groups.google.com/ and enter your query.
Gary KW4Z wrote:
your far better off to go with 2 standard larger tanks.
are you trying to get endlkess hot water? or more concerned with saving
a little money on energy?
2 tankless will require large gas service and remember a power failure
probably means no hot water
standard tanks even forced thru wall vents have enough hot water stored
for a couple showers
If I understand correctly, one correctly sized tankless could supply enough
hot water for all the appliances plus showers and baths at the same time. As
for the electric outages, a UPS - uninterruptible power supply, just for the
controls - should take care of that.
My concern is the reliability, and I hear some of the tankless heaters are
not good. I've been using hot water dispensers for years and those tanks
goes out about 5 years (something always goes out in about 5 years) and I
just couldn't justify replacing a tankless every 5 or even 10 years. Hot
water heater: $500, Tankless: $3,000. Tankless has to save a lot of energy
to justify the extra cost. Anyone know what the payback is for tankless?
the payback period exceeds the expected life of the unit, say 10 years
thats the longest warranty on a tankless. any companies locally for
so for 500 bucks you can get a standard tank with a 12 year warranty.
you would have to save more than 2500 bucks before saving a dime in
energy.:( check the energy guide labels of tanks thats probably the
entire operating cost of a regular tank. mine says 250 bucks a year,
times 10 years wheres the savings?
worse assuming your tank in in a heated part of the home the wasted
energy in the heating season helps heat your home so its not wasted at
all....... for the heating season. true its a loser for AC:(
new regular tanks are actually very efficent, you can get higfher btu
models and larger tanks for never run out showers if you want. my 50
gallong 75,000 btu is near that, next tank will be 75 gallons, the 50
barely fit my existing space.... new furnace and more space.
think of another thing regular tanks are actually very reliable, other
than spring a leak at end of life few have other troubles and are a
bargain at 500 bucks.
you could likely save a few hundered a year in heating costs for your
new home by doubling wall thickness and upgraded insulation...... at
say 30 grand extra.
thats not a good deal either
Not for nothing, but my 40 gal gas (spec grade) was installed when the house
was new in 1978 and is still going strong.
Tankless are really good for cabins and the like. Don't believe I would put
one in a new home unless it serves a single fixture located a long distance
from the water heater.
Just doesn't make any cents (don't forget to figure additional costs for
increased gas lines, larger meter, assoc. as well.)
We put in a Paloma PH6-DP in 1987, and have never made a repair
(although I bought a similar unit, for parts, for $50. about 15 years
ago- hard to find these old units). My local propane distributor has
one like it for their kitchen/ washrooms. We also cook with gas. Our
water pressure is about 20psi max (gravity system from a spring up the
hill) and this thing has always worked fine for us (family of 7 then,
3 now).The only thing I'd want different is the auto lighter- piezo or
"the little turbine" (Bosch), because of the gas- but the unit is on
the wall next to the toilet (in NW earthquake country- 2 shakes, no
problems), so it probably heats that space- a little.
We do have a small place- around 1000sq'- and the space for a tank is
also an issue. When we heated and cooked with wood, I had a tank that
ran through the woodstove... and took all insulation off of it- using
it as a radiator, as well as a hot water tank. That setup, w/ a solar
water panel, would be my favored Luddite fallback mode...
Amen to that... I'd favor going to radiant floor heating, if the house
is situated to take advantage of that... and, if I lived in horse 'n
dairy country, I'd go for the 250 sq' slab with pipes embedded, on the
downwind side of the house, upon which manure is piled, to fire the
heat exchanger in my own slab flooring... ^..^
7 LAMPSTICKS 7 FEASTS 7 AGES OF DISPENSATION 7 BOWLS 7 TRUMPETS 7 SEALS
And an earlier quote from this know it all:
I like the depth of knowledge that you expound on this thread but I do like
your quoted statements! Now go away and bother some other group with your
depth of knowledge please! Maybe alt.youdontknowwhatiknow.andicanproveit
I have the Bosch and would recommend it. It has a built in ignition system
that runs by the water turning a wheel to create the spark so it will even
work when the electric fails. I bought the smaller 1 use at a time unit but
for a family of 3 or more I would recommend the larger unit. But for me the
1 use is just fine. It installed easily (by myself) and has worked
flawlessly for 3 months that I have had it.
I had a Noritz N-069M http://www.noritz.com/n069.html in my newly
home of about 2500 sqft with 3 1/2 baths. I love it! With no circulation
at all, most hot water locations get hot water within a minute. The only
wait time for hot water is the master shower, it takes about 2 minutes. But
jetted tub just a few feet from the master shower gets hot water in about 30
More water volume to the tub vs. the shower head really cranks up the
I'm in west Texas with very hard water - it is highly recommended that you
a water softner in place in hard water conditions.
Give Noritz a pre-sales call, they were very helpful when I spoke to them.
I considered zoning two units, but the sales guy conviced me the N-069M
sufficient, but suggested that if you ever needed to, you could simply add a
second unit. They are designed to work in tandem with a connector cable.
No, the wait time is almost all emptying the pipes between the heater
and the fixture. The tankless heater adds at most 10 seconds to the
wait time. So you get hot water at the tub faster because the higher
flow rate empties the hot water pipes quicker.
On Thu, 4 Jan 2007 09:11:51 -0600, "Bob Dozier"
:I had a Noritz N-069M http://www.noritz.com/n069.html in my newly
:home of about 2500 sqft with 3 1/2 baths. I love it! With no circulation
:at all, most hot water locations get hot water within a minute. The only
:wait time for hot water is the master shower, it takes about 2 minutes. But
:jetted tub just a few feet from the master shower gets hot water in about 30
:More water volume to the tub vs. the shower head really cranks up the
:I'm in west Texas with very hard water - it is highly recommended that you
:a water softner in place in hard water conditions.
:Give Noritz a pre-sales call, they were very helpful when I spoke to them.
:I considered zoning two units, but the sales guy conviced me the N-069M
:sufficient, but suggested that if you ever needed to, you could simply add a
:second unit. They are designed to work in tandem with a connector cable.
I have the same unit: Model N-069M-OD. It includes the remote control
unit, which I use on a daily basis. I set the temperature somewhere
between 110 and 120 depending on the weather when I'm going to take a
shower and leave it at the lowest setting (100 degrees) for sink stuff
(the rest of the time, except laundry). It cost $4000 including
professional installation. It was installed by virtue of a city
sponsored program, so it didn't cost me a cent. Part of why they did it
was to solve the problem of how to route a vent for my dryer. Putting
the water heater outside (which is how these are installed) resolved
that problem. The water heater it replaced was a standard 40 gallon gas
tank heater. I would never have had the idea of going tankless if the
rep hadn't suggested it, and I wasn't going to refuse!
It works OK. I realize that at this point I'm on my own and I just hope
it lasts a real long time because I don't presently like the idea of
spending big bucks to fix or replace it.
I have a question about it myself, being how it deals with changes in
demand. Obviously as flow of hot water increases or decreases the unit
has to respond by decreasing or increasing the gas flame so that the
water comes out at the appropriate temperature. I wonder if _overusing_
this will cause something to go bad. IOW, is it better to leave the flow
when washing dishes in the sink at one flow rate or is it OK to keep
changing the flow rate like I always did with my tank water heater.
The responses in this thread already taught me one thing: I think I need
a UPS if I don't want to do without hot water in the event of a power
failure. I guess it's no big deal, actually. Power failures, at least
ones that last longer than a few seconds, are pretty rare here. Being
without power would be a much bigger inconvenience than being without
hot water. And I guess a UPS that would supply power for more than 1/2
hour or so is going to be costly. So's a generator.
And I guess a UPS that would supply power for more than 1/2
Should be cheap as not much power required to control the gas fired unit. Go
to any office or computer store and get one suitable for you unit - should
be under $100. You need to replace the UPS battery once every few years.
ahh check the current use of the tankless, if it uses a fan for exhaust
you may need a really large UPS.
did you knpow there are commercial size regular hot water tanks, they
can supply a hotel continiously so one home would be easy.. kinda
pricey but available
My Takagi draws less than an amp maximum, and that's briefly while the
blower is clearing the exhaust after the burner shuts off; most of the
time it's much lower draw. Any decent UPS can handle 120W loads.
email@example.com is Joshua Putnam
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.