Spent Saturday fixing the agitator on my 1972 Lady Kenmore and it washes like new again

Nov 18, 2026 Last reply: 1 day ago 5 Replies
Saved reading
Jump to replies (5)

The old girl has been spinning the agitator freely for months while the clothes just sat there. Pulled the agitator out Saturday and sure enugh, the little plastic dogs inside were worn down to almost nothing. They're what grip the shaft to make the one-way ratcheting motion, and after fifty-some years of wash days they were basically round.



Unplugged the machine, four bolts, and the whole agitator came apart in my hands. Ordered a new set of dogs for a few bucks and they went in without any drama. Reassembled it, ran a load of towels, and the clothes are rolling over top to bottom the way they did when Nixon was in office. My wife acutally commented that the jeans came out cleaner.



What gets me is that everything else on this set is still original. Same motor, same transmission, same dryer heating it up next to it. The repair took me about an hour with a socket set and a screwdriver. Try saying that about anything built in the last decade.


Reading this took me back to my mom's Lady Kenmore we finally retired in 2019 when the transmission finally let go. Before that it was forty-some years of nothing but agitator dogs, a couple of belts, and one lid switch my dad bypassed with a paperclip for a week until the real part came in the mail. Never touched the motor or pump once in all that time.

I've got a mid-80s Maytag in the basement now that's the same story. When my daughter's socks started coming out soaked, I figured it was the end of the road, but it turned out to be a worn drive belt and a lid switch with corroded contacts. Maybe thirty bucks total and an afternoon of cussing at a stubborn snap ring. One thing I'd add for anyone keeping these old girls alive: a tube of appliance grease on the agitator splines when you've got it apart saves you a stripped cam down the road. I learned that after the dogs on my Maytag chewed up the metal hub because I skipped it the first time. The saddest part is I could probably fix the new washer my wife wanted, but everything's sealed up behind proprietary clips and I'd need a laptop and a subscription to diagnose a pump. I kept the old Kenmore's service manual in a drawer just on principle.

I've got the sister to your situation, sort of. When we bought our house in 2011 it came with a mid-70s Lady Kenmore washer and matching dryer, and I kept the pair running for years with basic tools and parts ordered from a supply house two towns over. The washer was the easy one. Inlet valve, a belt, one timer knob, done. But the dryer wore me down. Thermostat went, then the drum belt, then the felt seal started shredding and leaving black streaks on everything white. After the third repair in two years I stopped putting money into it and bought the cheapest new dryer the appliance store had in stock. Honestly, it dries the same. Maybe faster, since the old one took forever and ticked so loud you could hear the timer from the kitchen. What surprised me was the electric bill. The new dryer runs noticeably less per load and the difference actually shows up month to month. So now I'm running a fifty-year-old washer with a five-year-old dryer and that combo has been fine for a family of four. My point is that the washer is the machine worth babying. The transmissions in those old Kenmores are the reason they last. The dryers, in my experiance, were always the weaker half of the set, and there's no shame in letting that one go and putting your repair hours into the machine that actually earns them.

Did the same dance on my aunt's 70s Kenmore a couple summers back. The dogs were fine but the agitator itself was frozen to the splined shaft and would not budge. What saved me was an agitator coupler puller, seven bucks at the hardware store, threads into the agitator and pops it right off the shaft. I'd spent an hour yanking on it by hand like an idiot before I broke down and bought one. Greased the splines on reassembly and she's been quiet as ever since.

Funny how the jeans coming out cleaner is the real test. Mine did the same thing after I replaced the dogs, like the machine had been quietly getting worse for a year and we just blamed the detergent. Something else I noticed, the old girl fills way deeper than my buddy's new HE machine. He swears his cleans fine but I've seen his stuff come out with the soap still on it. Anyway, enjoy the win. Those belt-drive Whirlpool-built machines will outlive all of us if you keep feeding them ten dollar parts.

Since you had it apart anyway, check the base of the agitator itself for hairline cracks next time. On the 70s Kenmores the plastic around the bottom hub gets brittle, and I have seen one let go mid-spin and scatter chunks into the tub like shrapnel. The dogs get all the blame but the agitator body failing is the messier failure. Mine held for years with a crack I found by flexing it under the kitchen light, and a new agitator slid onto the same splines without any adaptation, which is exactly the kind of interchangeability you do not see anymore.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required