Plane collecting - Valuing broken planes?

Apr 06, 2005 1 Replies

For the less common Stanleys (the #10 family, #2 etc.) how much does a repaired break affect its value ? A large proportion of the #10s in particular show the classic broken mouth with a braze or weld to at least one side.



I've just been trying to put a value on a #2C Sweetheart with brazing to both sides of the mouth. Now that's a valuable little plane, even as a "user" grade tool



In similar vein, how about English infills that have suffered shrunken infill blocks, unsupported sides and the resultant lengthways sole cracks ? Again it's not a hard repair, but you have to take the cross pins out to dismantle it and they don't easily (shouldn't ?) go back without leaving a visible repair.



Andy Dingley wrote in news: snipped-for-privacy@4ax.com:

I have no answer, except to point you to a potential resource.

There are a whole bunch of folks at

formatting link
, in the hand tools forum, who might be able to offer an opinion. Some of them hang out here, too, or used to. And you can post a picture or two, if you have one.

Patriarch, thinking a #2 might be a nice addition to the tool shelf, IF he were a collector...

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required