My first choice when I need something is Menards, then Home Depot, then
Fleet Farm and Lowes is a no choice. I went there on opening day and
Lowes is a bi-lingual store, so I told the mgr. that since I am not
bi-lingual, good-bye. Their prices weren't that good anyway.
Menards was a so-so store until HD came to town, then Lowes and now they
are much much better with their stocking procedure, quality, service.
I feel here in Springfield, IL Lowe's has the best construction lumber.
Menard's requires a lot of picking through to find a good 2X4. A lot of it
is junk wood. However, I find that Menard's has the best cabinet plywood
( Baltic birch, birch, oak, and maple). When you buy birch ply there you
have to make sure you get the best grade. They have 2 grades of 3/4 birch,
1 for around 20 bucks ( which has voids in it and looks ok from the outside)
is crappy, the other sells for 30 dollars or more is OK. I haven't seen much
cabinet grade at Lowe's, They don't have much of a selection for
woodworkers. If they do have it, it's a lot higher than Menard's. Their
tools there at Lowe's are fine. We don't have a Home Depot here.
I buy very little of the construction grade lumber since I do mostly
furniture building and I get my red oak from a local wood provider at
about 40% of the cost. My last buy was red oak for $2.25 bf, and all
good stuff. When I do want construction I will hit HD first, then Menards.
Every body has good and bad wood. I once bought some 2x4x96 boards at
Lowes down the street. By the time I got them home some of the perfect
boards I bought had a 90 degree twist in them. Must have been the change
in temperature/humidity. ;^)
Generally they are bigger in size than Lowes or HD, carry more
hardwoods (shrink wrapped even). Have a broader selection of price
levels than the other two.
That seems to be the case here in Southern Illinois.
Where I live, there's not a Menards. When my wife and I visit her
parents in Cedar Rapids, Iowa I somehow manage to always get myself
volunteered for some type of project. That typically breaks down to
about 10 trips to Menards, 5 to Home Depot, 1 or 2 to Lowe's, and
another 1 or 2 to Acme Tools. A lot of the trips to Menards are just
because it's the closest, but also because they have more selection.
In particular I like that Mendards carries hardwood moldings and
have a selection of S4S hardwoods as well. It is odd though
buying hardwood boards that are shrink wrapped. But these are things
that neither Home Depot or Lowes ever carries.
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.