When I ran out of the Minwax wipe-on I usually use, I decided to make my own by diluting Var poly with 25% more mineral spirits. It did just fine until I did my 5th and final application. It was not at all satisfactory; lumpy and varied appearance. I went at it with steel wool and put down another final application. It was just as bad. More steel wool; this time I diluted a bit thinner, but the result was the same. (I expect the first 5 applications were uneven also, but I wasn't expecting them to look finished, so it didn't matter)
I bought some Minwax wipe-on and it went on as even as can be.
Presumably I am doing something wrong, since so many of you talk about making your own wipe-on. Any hints as to why I had problems? The home made is about half the price of prepared, so I would like to keep using it; but I have a feeling it is more than just dilute regular. Thanks.