OT Performing rights...

Aug 30, 2012 52 Replies
Saved reading

In article , Tim Lamb writes

I think it's a good idea for him not to engage either telephone callers or physical callers in any dialogue over the use of the radio.

I don't view playing a radio in a workshop with one person a 'performance' and so would resist any attempt to license my use whether the rules make it a requirement or not. The trouble is that by asking the right questions a talented questioner can have an unsuspecting respondent admitting to all sorts of nonsense that could in their view justify chasing him to pay.

My approach there for would be, on the phone, to politely refuse to discuss the matter with them, ask them not to call again and to hang up if they attempt to continue the dialogue. If they appear in person I would again refuse to discuss the matter and would ask them to leave, "you are on private property, please leave[1]". If they write, ignore the letter, any careless remark used in a reply could be used against him.

Say nowt and don't dig any holes (like the prat with the well in his lounge, "I've dug down 17 feet already" . . . . er, why?).

[1] If the term, "visitors are not permitted here" was added then this could be helpful later in stating only unauthorised visitors (trespassers) could have heard the radio.

Probably true. I think I would be inclined to get them to send me details, and then when they pester in the future just tell them you have looked at their information and made an assessment that no license is required, and not enter into any further conversation. That way you can avoid disclosing anything.

Indeed.

What I don't know in this situation, is what the legal powers and status of the PRS are/is. Even if they are actually quite limited (e.g. like TV licensing - just another sub contracted commercial organisation) they are unlikely to make this clear.

For example, say they assess your business, and deem a license is required and then send you bill you for it, is the status of that just the same as any other unsolicited invoice?

IIUC copyright in this country is a civil mater, so presumably any enforcement would need to be through the courts - how would they view the bill - would a contract exist?

in general, if a person leaves his/her home to watch or listen to copyright material it is considered to be a "perforamnce". I don't, however, suppose that anyone has attempted to get a copyright fee off the cars that sound like mobile ghetto blasters ;-)

To keep interaction to a minimum I'd be more inclined to say that I had already looked into the rules and found that a license was not required (and refuse further discussion). That should be a closed discussion with no further contact required. With the former they have an excuse to call back and try to catch you out again :-).

"Could you send me out some details of that?" "Yes" "Do you have my address" "No"

In article , charles writes

Thanks for that, all the more reason to keep the gob shut then, it appears to be a minefield.

Mind you, in the case of the headphoned ipod user near me on the train yesterday, it was definitely a public performance :-/

For the small hall community hall I look after the situation just got worse. PRS now combines with PPL, demanding their own fee and collecting PPL's as well. They both have a scale of charges depending on amount of activity. Our hall's level of activity is way below their lowest threshold and thus attracts their minimum fee - it just happens to be almost 10% of our annual intake! Our users do play CDs so ....

Can anyone explain to me what PPL is charging for that PRS isn't?

FRank

PPL are charging you for playing the CD (the money goes to the record company)

PRS are charging you for playing the music on the CD (the money goes to the singer and songwriter)

And Mechanical Copyright will charge you for using the CD in an MP3 collection ...

Owain

formatting link
"PRS for Music, at its discretion, does not make a charge for music used at a recognised Service of Divine Worship in consecrated places of worship (of any recognised faith), where no charge is made to attendees for admission."

Problem solved. You just nominate wherever it is as a place of worship of the Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster.

"At it's discretion", "consecrated place", "recognised faith"... that's the sort of mealy-mouthed nonsense you associate with Corgi telling you it's illegal to do gas work.

"where no charge is made to attendees for admission"... so if the collection plate went round, they could withdraw their discretion and really come down hard on them?

While I think your views on the PRS calls are sensible, not sure why you don't understand why investigating a well like that can actually be fairly interesting to people other than you.

The TV licence people are known for assuming every household has a TV. And the DVLA will certainly chase you if they have evidence of you having a car but it isn't taxed etc. Rather like the evidence that the OP was playing a radio in other than his dwelling.

The DVLA will know you have a car. The PRS doesn't know you have a radio, there is no recording of sales.

And the TVLA have no records of people that watch a TV.

They bombarded my company with five threatening letters in three weeks in which I was abroad

They then phoned up a few days after I got back

Well, you know how I love to get a bit sweary at times ...

they have never phoned up again

We also had a couple of what can only be classed as threatening letters from TV licensing shortly before the olympics - both of which, of course, went straight in the bin

In message , charles writes

Or the bastard you end up sitting next to on the underground with his personal stereo going full blast

In message , tim..... writes

HMRC have only ever contacted my by mail, I have never been cold called by them

Sending PAYE/NIC payments too *early* seems to confuse them, they end up allocating it to wrong months, then phone up to complain you haven't paid them the following month, even though they can see the 'double' payment the month before.

Ask them for a comprehensive list of all the all the artists that they represent so you can be sure to avoid playing their music

or ...

tell them where to go

Not for me, they first used to send your check back as they can't allocate it, they then send you a snotty letter regarding late payment, which is finally followed up by a cheque fore £1.20 as the interest on the original cheque you sent them

I've often wondered if it would be possible to generate, with a portable device, an EMP sufficient to fry all the "personal" steroes within earshot.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required