Off topic as usual. Drax farce

BBC Look North this lunchtime

More outrageous bias from ?The world?s most trusted broadcaster?

The lead story was that Drax is going to stop burning coal completely, and will only burn wood chip. Hurrah! The world is saved! Big smiles from the presenter and the reporter; you?d think it was VE Day ? except neither of them would know what that was. They pretended to consider the holes in this greeny narrative, but of course it was a sham. They only found a few tiny holes; ones that could easily be darned apparently ? they didn?t discover the massive unfixable voids in the logic of the whole crazy idea. The report was nothing more than a press release for the Green Party. They wheeled on a guy in a Drax hard hat (smart suit + hard hat = voice of authority?), who said, deadpan, that the woodchip was all made from waste wood, and if woodchip wasn?t burnt at Drax it would be burnt in America, where it comes from. This would ?release CO2 into the atmosphere.? Err, that?s what?s happens when it?s burnt at Drax! In any case, more and more stories are coming from the US suggesting that it isn?t 100% scrap wood at all. There was no mention of the CO2 produced when the woodchip is transported by truck, ship, and train to Drax. Drax is, apparently, the UK?s biggest CO2 emitter. The green concept is that these emissions don?t matter, because for every tree burnt another one is planted, and that tree will absorb CO2. Two snags: Trees absorb approximately the same amount of CO2 as the green pasture or crop that they replace, and it takes a tree thirty to fifty years to absorb the amount of CO2 that burning it will release. Since the ?climate emergency? is allegedly upon us right now, that?s not much help is it? The burning of wood pellets causes Drax to emit particulate matter. Drax is one of the top five emitters of PM10 air pollution in Europe. I suppose if the world is going to end in a few years (© Prince Charles, God help us, our next monarch) everyone downwind of Drax might as well die of lung cancer.

Reply to
williamwright
Loading thread data ...

+1 and hollow laughter. Not only that, but Drax has just had its green credentials withdrawn
formatting link
Even more hollow laughter.
Reply to
Chris Hogg

I seem to recall a Ch4 (I think) documentary that tracked the supply of the woodchip back to the US of A and retraced the journey.

The theory was that old and dead woodland was to be used but in practice good woodland was cleared.

And the carbon footprint only started once the fuel arrived at the UK powerplant (can't recal if it was Drax or some other, in Yorkshire iirc).

As an aside but still related to "greenwashing" I was looking at buying some golf tees from the pro shop this morning and noticed they were all wooden. I asked the pro if they were better than plastic ones and he didn't make a firm comment other than to say they were greener. So I asked if they lasted as long to which he admitted they broke more readily, to which I commented "so more trees to be felled to make up for the broken wooden tees!" and again - no comment, just a wry smile.

Reply to
AnthonyL

In one way they are greener - that lost or broken wooden tee will have been eaten (probably by fungi) in a couple of years. The plastic ones will be around for millennia.

Andy

Reply to
Vir Campestris

It also means the golf course won't gradually turn into a plastic waste dump as all the discarded tees build up in the ground. Which is probably something the golf course owners care about. I could imagine them mandating wooden tees for that reason.

Wonder if you can get biodegradable golf balls? (ah, it seems you can)

Theo

Reply to
Theo

HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.