The spiral on metal chimneys that is. I used to think it was about having the wind help draw gases out of the chimney. In fact it about preventing wind eddies shaking the chimney to destruction.
Now I know what the spiral is for
Jun 02, 2015
30 Replies
In article , Harry Bloomfield scribeth thus
Yes quite correct, as can be seen by some spirals here on the top of the Emley mast in Yorkshire;)..
formatting link
Yes, I knew about that 30 years ago, but what I couldn't get my head around (if it's true) is that it only works when the spiral is in one particular direction, not the other.
Yep. Vortex shedding.
Tim
Does it depend which hemisphere you're in? :)
Not true.
formatting link
To bring this closer to DIY - wrapping a spiral of cable around the top rung of a stepladder being transported on the roof rack of my car results in a much quieter journey. (If the top rung is at the front.)
John
That is what I was thinking, as correolis would suggest it should be the other way darn sarf. Brian
Yes as well as industrial chimneys the effect can be seen at the other end of the scale on some car antennae, to stop them resonating at certain speeds
formatting link
formatting link
But its far to localized for Coriolis to have any effect.
Must explain why it's seen with plug holes.
It isn't
formatting link
(and an infinite supply of other links if you choose to look)
Harry Bloomfield put finger to keyboard:
Greek bridge prog last night by any chance? I was impressed by the video of the dampers in the earthquake.
Where you watching "Impossible Engineering" on Discovery science?
Whoosh!
Tim
It isn't.
You were obviously never a small boy. This small boy soon discovered that you can force the water going down a plug hole to rotate in either direction by use of a mark 1 finger. Further, that the water continues to rotate that way until there is none left.
Urban myth. It works because it suppresses vortex shedding by disrupting the axial symmetry.
The problem with vortex shedding is resonance when the natural frequency of the chimney, tower, or whatever coincides with the vortex shedding frequency.
Brian probably couldn't see the smiley.
Witness the Tacoma narrows bridge.
formatting link
Usually described as forced resonance the full story is of aeroelastic flutter but for the purposes of a Usenet post it can be thought of as forced resonance.
Yerrs, BUT left to its won devices it nearly always rotated anticlockwise, the same ways as a depression rotates in the Northern hemisphere.
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required