EDF and smart meters

Anyone else getting pestered with increasing frequency by EDF about having a smart meter installed?

I see that my EDF MyAccount preference of "Never having a smart meter" had been changed to "I want a smart meter". I've changed it back, although they don't make it easy to do so.

Reply to
Jeff Layman
Loading thread data ...

Yep. I doubt it would stop them almost doubling my monthly direct debit though.

I didn't know there was such a setting. Can I set it to 'I had one installed by a factory tenant, it was nothing but trouble and I will make an appointment only after hell freezes over'?

Reply to
Colin Bignell

To answer my own question, it seems I can, although I chose to modify the last bit. Thank you for the heads up on the existence of that preference.

Reply to
Colin Bignell

They have given up with me after a couple of years

Reply to
The Natural Philosopher

no, but I have set the preference about smartmeters to "no" in their online system.

Reply to
Andy Burns

If they reset your 'Preference' once without consulting you, I doubt if it will make much difference.

P.S. The calibration period for gas & electricity meters is 10 years. How old are your current(sic) meters, and what will you do[1] when they fall out of calibration?

[1] Plus, what will your energy supplier do?
Reply to
Sam Plusnet

So had I. They changed it back. It's back to "never" again, but for how long I couldn't say.

Reply to
Jeff

At the moment, you can still request non-smart replacements and you either get re-calibrated, older meters or new smart meters, with the comms inactive.

How long that will last for, I don't know.

Reply to
SteveW

If only it were so simple.

10 is the limit for new approvals under the national scheme but it can be extended in the light of experience; and is extended in practice with some meters having 15, 20 and 40 years.

Then there's meters approved under the European Measuring Instruments Directive for which there's no set period.

Reply to
Robin

The electric meter was replaced about 6 years ago (it's a static one - no dials). The gas meter is at least 10 years old. If I can get a old meter, that's what I'll do. I understand that a "smart" gas meter cannot exist without a smart electric meter, as it requires that for communication. So if I don't replace the electric meter, the gas meter will be "dumb" even if they try to put in a smart one.

No doubt lie by saying I have no choice and have to have a smart meter. If there really is no dumb meter available, I'll probably have to go with a smart meter but insist it remains uncommunicative with the supplier. The problem is that I doubt anyone could confirm that it is not communicating.

Reply to
Jeff Layman

You're welcome, but it almost certainly won't last as they'll reset it themselves.

Reply to
Jeff Layman

But now I know it exists, I know what to do when he reminders start to appear again.

Reply to
Colin Bignell

Enclose the communications hub in a Faraday cage?

Reply to
Colin Bignell

In message <tvd8pd$9ff0$ snipped-for-privacy@dont-email.me, at 21:49:33 on Tue, 21 Mar

2023, Jeff Layman snipped-for-privacy@invalid.invalid remarked:

I'm not sure that's entirely true. Each of the two smart meters needs a mains-powered "hub" to communicate back to base. AIUI, for convenience many electricity smart meters have an integral hub, which the gas meter is also paired with. But you could still have a free-standing hub.

Reply to
Roland Perry

Thanks for the clarification. I've just been reading up on hubs - including the newer dual-band ones, and DCC. I see that a lot more money is due to be wasted on smart meters in the south of England. From

formatting link
: "The government and UK mobile network operators have agreed to phase out

2G and 3G mobile networks by 2033 in order to free up bandwidth for 5G and future 6G services. This includes Telefónica (O2) who provide the Smart Meter communications for the Central and Southern regions of the UK.

This change will require the replacement of communications hubs on the Smart Electricity Meters in the Central and Southern regions of the UK. To this end the DCC plan to have 4G single band Communications Hubs available in 2023, with dual band to follow in Q2 2024."

So all SMETS2 hubs installed in the southern half of the UK are effectively already obsolete! Wasn't the original cost of smart meter installation supposed to be around £11billion? I wonder what the final figure for this apparently bottomless money pit will be! Far from saving us money, smart meters will continue to cost us all a fortune for many years to come.

Reply to
Jeff Layman

Our meter is well past 10 years and I've had one prompt to change to a smart meter which claimed 10 years was the limit. However I told them I don't want a smart meter and I've heard nothing more so our 'old' meter soldiers on! :-)

Reply to
Chris Green

The certification period is more "best before" than "use by". And they've covered their arse by offering you a new one.

Reply to
Robin

It's a convenient ruse for them in many cases, similar to the "we need to do a gas safety check" ruse, which in most cases is just a way to let the meter reader have access ...

Reply to
Andy Burns

It seems their argument is that if the meter reads too high the customer won't be able to claim anything back as a "correctly operating" meter had been offered and rejected.

Well, that argument works the other way too. What happens if it reads too low? Or stops working completely. Does the utility company then conjure up an estimate based on previous usage? If so, why shouldn't that be used for a too-high reading from a faulty meter? And perhaps someone here can help explain how an old analogue (dial) meter could read too high, whether gas or electricity? I would have thought it far more likely to fail by the gears playing up or getting jammed and giving too low a reading.

Reply to
Jeff Layman

Yep, its arse covering. There has always been a rolling meter replacement scheme with a target of around 10 years for the exchanges, although this target probably hasn't been met for the past 50 years. It's more to do with guaranteeing some accuracy and calibration of the meter(s). People may have had letters 20 or 30 years ago asking for them to make an appointment for a meter check or exchange. By not replying or refusing their utility company collective arses are covered because they have offered a replacement and you can no longer claim money back for

10/20 years of the meter reading incorrectly.

In the past the replacement may not have been a new meter but a reconditioned meter or one that had just been checked/calibrated for accuracy.

Reply to
alan_m

HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.