Can an NFC external reader for mobile also be used as a desktop RFID reader?

Oct 30, 2025 Last reply: 8 months ago 6 Replies

I need to authenticate my shiny new Italian electronic ID card (we've gone digital!).



For that, I need either:



- a smartphone with NFC, or - a desktop external RFID reader



as per instructions:



formatting link
"The device can be your smartphone (if equipped with NFC technology) on which you have installed the CieID app, or a computer with a smart card reader on which you have installed the CIE software"


I also need to update my documents on my UKVI account and I might also need RFC for this.



As I have none of the above, I was thing of buying an external NFC/RFID reader that I could use for both mobile and PC (Linux in this case).



Does it make sense? Are NFC and RFID more or less the same thing?



Would an NFC external reader for mobile also be used as a desktop RFID reader?



What do I have to look for when buying one of these?



Do the instructions give any indication of what to do if you do not have modern electronic gizmos? Do you remain inauthentic?

Presumably you know your .it tax code, and sounds like they'll send your PUK code with the new ID, based on those two it sounds like you have a method to activate the card without NFC?

Other than that, do you have a burning desire to read your own ID card?

ish ... not all RFID is NFC, NFC uses the 13.5 MHz version of RFID

formatting link

Mobile reader could be USB or Bluetooth, if you're on Linux I'd ask carefully how compatible it is.

It's been a lomg time (~15yr) since I worked with USB smartcard readers (PC/SC) and I've never worked with the Android NFC stack, but I would assume they aren't compatible, and some brief searching seems to agree.

You can get external readers for Android phones but they're intended for a specific app like price labels or door entry or whatever. I would not assume a regular NFC-using app is going to work with them, as there doesn't appear to be a way for the Android NFC stack to use external devices.

Unless you want to buy another phone, probably your best bet is a USB reader passed through to a Windows VM running their software.

Theo

Am 30.10.25 um 17:01 schrieb Andy Burns:

You can activate it without NFC, but you don't get the magical "Level 3" which the one you need to do just about everything, such as booking an appointment, applying for a new document, etc.

See above.

Given your current phone has VoLTE issues with spusu and doesn't have NFC, I'd say an upgrade would kill two birds with one stone.

I probably will, but my Huawei has a non-Google app that allows me to record all incoming and outgoing calls and this functionality has been removed on plain-vanilla Android.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required