When it cuts out, does it continue to hum? Or gurgle or make any sounds whatsoever for that matter? Is the filter clogged?Â
On the 201250 pump you should be able to remove the impeller guard (aka inlet cover). Open the nose, remove the filter, there will be four screws on the face of the inlet cover, remove those. Remove the cover, see if the impeller is intact - it's known to break blades lose - and there's no debris wedged between the cover and the impeller. See if it starts with the guard off, just be careful and not run it for long. Listen for any funny sounds.
If it won't start with the inlet cover off, I would leave it submerged in a bucket for a day and then come back and see if there's any oil on the surface of the water. If there is, it's leaking, need to send it back. If there isn't, most likely still need to send it back. Because of the water tight seals it was not designed to be serviceable on site.