Hi,
Well here it is January and I posted about this problem back in July so I guess I procrastinated a little bit! But I actually fixed our towel rods and I am pretty happy with myself for being able to do this project.
So in case anyone else is in the same predicament, here is what I did to fix the problem.
Problem : Towel rods kept getting pulled out of wall due to people leaning on the rod and the plastic anchors were not sufficient to keep them in place. Relocating was not an option because of recent wall paper job.
Solution : Toggle Bolts! I had enough sheet rock left to work with that I was able to slip 1/8 by 2 inch toggle bolts into the existing holes and then I was able to fasten the clip securely to the wall and get a much more secure connection.
I'm sure if someone puts full weight on it it will come out again but hopefully they will stay put for a while.
I am not exactly Mr. fixit so any time I am able to do one of these little projects I am pretty happy about it.
Thanks for the tips back in July!
Steve