Permeable pavers or just regrade the whole driveway? Rain pooling situation in LA

Oct 30, 2026 Last reply: 2 weeks ago 6 Replies
Saved reading
Jump to replies (6)

So every winter storm we get this big puddle right where my driveway meets the backyard, and it sits there for days. The slope kind of funnels everything toward that one corner near the fence. Neighbor says he fixed a similar problem by cutting in a channel drain, but that means sawing up concrete and I'm not sure I want to go that route. Been looking at ripping out part of the driveway and doing permeable pavers instead, since I figure that whould let the water soak in instead of running off. But I've also heard they can clog up over time with all the dust and debris we get out here, and then you're back to pooling anyway. Is that true or is it mostly hype? The other option is just regrading so everything tilts toward the street instead. Cheaper probly, but then I'm just sending all that water to the storm drain when it could actually be soaking into my yard somewhere. My backyard is mostly dirt and a sad little lawn, so a rain garden or somthing in that corner might work too.



Anyone in LA deal with this? What actually held up for you, and what would you skip if you did it again?


I'm in Van Nuys and dealt with almost the same corner-puddle situation about four years back. I skipped the pavers and just dug a shallow rain garden in the low spot, maybe 8 by 5 feet and about 6 inches deep at the center, with a slight swale leading into it. I planted it with carex, yarrow, and a couple of sage plants from the nursery on Laurel Canyon, topped it with mulch, and now the water that used to sit for days is gone within a day after a storm. The lawn got smaller but I honestly don't miss it. On the clogging question, it's not hype, but it's manageable. My brother-in-law has a permeable strip in Burbank and he has to vacuum it with a shop vac a couple times a year because the fines settle into the joints. Skip that chore for a few seasons and yes, it starts acting like regular concrete again. Regrading toward the street would've solved my puddle too, but like you said it just moves the water somewhere else, and LA charges you on runoff anyway in some cases. If your corner is near the fence and away from the house foundation, a basin is a weekend of shovel work and a few hundred bucks in plants and mulch versus thousands for saw-cutting or repaving. The dirt in my yard soaked it up way better than I expected once I broke the crust on the surface.

I'm up in Highland Park and I actually did the permeable pavers six winters ago, and the clogging thing hasn't been a real problem for me. I sweep the surface a couple times a year and top up the joint sand each fall before the rains, maybe a 20 minute job. The corner where water used to sit for a week now drains within a day of the storm passing. What matters more than the pavers is what's under them. You have to dig out several inches of the old base and put down open-graded gravel, and that gravel layer is where most of the water actually goes. If a crew just lays pavers on compacted dirt you'll be right back where you started.

One thing I'd flag on the regrade option. My lot also tilts toward the street, and when I got quotes the regrading quote was not that much cheaper than the pavers, because they still had to tear out and repour or re-slope a big chunk of slab to change the fall. Plus in my case the water sheeting off toward the street was pooling at the sidewalk apron anyway, so I'd have traded a backyard puddle for a front one.

Before you commit either way, dig a test hole in that corner and fill it with water to see how fast your soil drains. Mine is slow clay, so the gravel base under the pavers does most of the work, not the ground itself. That answer changes what's worth spending on.

Toward the end of my yard I hit hardpan under the dirt, wich nobody warns you about untill you're two feet down and the shovel just bounces. A cheap fence-post auger on my drill was what got me through it, boring out a few deep holes I filled with gravel as little sump pits. That plus a shallow basin on top keeps my corner dry now, even in back-to-back storms. Worth checking what's under your soil before committing to any plan, because if you're sitting on hardpan like I was, the water has nowhere to go no matter what you plant on top.

I did the channel drain route in Eagle Rock three winters ago and it held up fine, for what that's worth. Contractor saw-cut a 10 foot run along the edge of the slab, dropped the drain in, piped it out to a dry well I dug myself. Took one day of labor total. The catch is the grate catches leaves, so I pop it out and rinse it maybe monthly during the season. If the concrete near your corner is alredy cracked or uneven, cutting is less painful than you'd think. But if your soil drains decent like the other folks here found, a basin really is the cheaper fix.

First post here so forgive me if this is dumb, but one thing that made a difference at my place (smaller version of your problem, puddle by the patio instead of the driveway) was figuring out where the roof water was actually going. One downspout dumped right at the low spot and I didn't even realize it until a storm hit. I stuck a cheap flexible extender on it to send water toward the side yard instead and the puddle shrank by like half before I did anything else. Might be worth checking if a downspout or the roof runoff is feeding your corner before you commit to cutting anything. Cheap to test at least.

Update: went with the rain garden idea from the Van Nuys poster, dug it in that low corner and it's handling the water way better than I expected. Hit some hard stuff down there like the other guy mentioned, but a shovel and patience got through. Still figuring out what to plant since part of it gets shade most of the day. Anyone have luck with carex in a shadier spot?

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required