The first thing you need to consider is what are you going to use the mitre
saw for? and how often will you use it? If you're just going to use it a few
times and then let it sit in the garage gathering dust then why pay a small
fortune when you can buy a cheapy one and forget about it after use. On the
other hand if you're going to be using it on a regular basis and you need
clean and accurate joints then pick a model which performs the task you need
it to perform..
I have a mitre block which my father knocked up 60 years ago from some
offcuts of floorboards and I still use it whenever I need a mitre joint and
so long as I take my time it provides a perfectly acceptable finish..
What jobs have you in mind for using the sliding mitre saw on?
I have an Axminster own label. I'm considering a Wickes own label to
replace it, they look pretty good for the money.
Do you need the extra cutting capacity of a sliding saw though?
Dave - The Medway Handyman
On Fri, 03 Apr 2009 07:34:09 GMT, "The Medway Handyman"
There have been times, and I have a job to do soon where it would be
As it happens, and in the absence of any other advice here, I'd
already narrowed it down to the very machine you've linked to above.
Wickes had already told me at the beginning of the week that they only
had 2 left, that this model was to be discontinued and replaced by
another supplier (similar spec) at just under £200, so I placed the
order this morning. The link is now empty so my guess is I bought the
last one or the penultimate.
However from my earlier research Wickes told me that #186891 was in
fact a Wickes-badged Draper saw and I strongly suspect it's identical
to the one I've linked below. The amazon deal (market place
retailer) is almost on a par but there's a delivery charge. The
second deal is pricier and there's an anomaly in the product
description (the header says 2000w but lower down it appears to have a
Out of curiosity I also phoned Draper to find out why the saw was
being discontinued. The guy I spoke to said it's very possibly because
the manufacturer (lol! it's not made by Wickes and it's also not made
by Draper!!) has possible filed for bankruptcy like a lot of their
suppliers! What's the world coming to?
(Amazon.com product link shortened)38779072&sr=1-2
With uncertainties over the warranty (manufacturer defunct) and better
price the amazon deal is a no-brainer if Wickes can no longer supply
Thanks for replying - best of luck.
(Amazon.com product link shortened)38779072&sr=1-2
They look amazingly similar to the one I bought two years ago from Aldi for
£49.99 complete with 3 years warranty. I have done a lot of work with it and
its still going strong. At that price I would have been happy if it fell
apart after I finished building the workshop which was the reason for buying
Here is what I built with it.
The roof is Steadmans AS2000,
Not cheap but as the workshop is in a very prominent spot as you come up the
drive to the house I wanted something reasonably attractive.
Thank you, I have to say I am quite proud of it especially as its all my own
work and design.
Yeah, well you'd definitely want one of those saws for that job - I'm
Looks like you struck gold with the Aldi purchase, though when I
checked their latest offering it appears to be a smaller blade. Still,
a very good deal.
I've come unstuck with cheap tools before and without specific
guidance usually stick to the get-what-you-pay-for principle...hence
my middle price range choice here. And a few positive online
I have had good use out of Aldi and Lidl tools. They mostly come with a 3
year warranty and I think that at the price a working tool guaranteed for 3
years is brilliant. Their replacement policy is good as well. I burnt out
the SDS hammer drill from Lidl after 2.5 years of quite heavy use. No
problem, telephoned the helpline and a new drill complete with case, bits,
and chisels etc was delivered FOC 4 days later. The compressor I bought from
Aldi came with a leaky connector on the end of the airline. No problem,
after a phone call to the helpline a new hose arrived in the post. I still
occasionally use the leaky one as an extension, they don't seem to want the
old ones back. The nail/staple gun I bought with the compressor was
fantastic for fixing all the cladding on the workshop.
I was going to say how fortunate you've been but I suspect a lot of
this generosity towards the consumer has been one of the many
spin-offs of the credit boom. It was probably unsustainable
retailing. I worry now that we'll regress to a phase when we get what
we're given and made to feel thankful for it - a vortex of
Of course, I hope not. I'll have a look at Aldi and Lidl when buying
my next tool.
I have an older Wickes saw. No laser, 2000w and a 1'' bore (the links below
are 16mm) and the sliding rails are shrouded inside some massively built
steel plate housing but as far as I can see it's basically the same model.
It is built like a tractor. Oodles of power.
There is no bypass for the depth of cut stop stop screw, so you can't make a
shallow cut, then a full depth cut then a stopped cut again without
re-setting the depth screw (and making test cuts again) each time. A flip-out
preset would have been a great improvement Probably only an issue if you are
making housings in shelf uprights etc which, frankly, are better done with a
router. The option would be nice, though.
There is a metric scale on the fence, but only on the right hand side which,
as the saw can only be operated right handed (rt thumb operated blade
guard/descent lock) means you can only use it if you are cutting "waste on
left". This means that the saw body is between the operator and the measured
piece, which just makes the scale useless. Hard to describe but you'd get my
drift immediately if you used it.
The carriage slide lock is ineffective and adjustment is impossible because
of the shrouding, which is also impossible to remove without a manual (yes,
I've tried) I can't locate a manual, or an exploded view, either.
In practice this isn't much of a problem but I would still prefer a
locked-down, non-sliding saw head unless I wanted it sliding.
12'' boards are no problem. If the sides are parallel, neither are 24" boards
- just flip the board front-to-back, line the kerf up again by eye/feel and
re-cut. I'm not saying you'll get a jointed edge, but unless you then want to
edge-band the cut without further sanding or planing. the 24" cut will be
good enough for most practical applications.
I keep a fine cross-cut blade on mine and use it for ALL cross cutting under
24"" - including panels - and therefore I can keep an excellent rip blade on
the table saw which doesn't need constant blade changing.
Lack of a laser is no problem. Just bring the stationary blade down to a
scribed cut line and eyeball it. Probably more accurate than the laser
anyway. I don't see the point of a laser which only operates when the blade
is spinning... surely the time to line the blade up is when it is stationary?
What do I know.. ? Only that I'd prefer to reach the end of my days with the
same number of fingers I started with.
Wickes/Draper/SIP saw, overall?
tremendous, rugged piece of kit with some minor annoyances.
Would I go for another?
Definitely, if the niggles were fixed and I believe they may have been with
the current model but I can only review the one I have
if you want help/advice/backup from Wickes, forget it.
In my experience they are staffed by nerds who don't give a toss, know
nothing about the products and are happy to misinform and mislead customers
just so they can get back to giggling with their mates in a corner as quickly
e.g. I heard the local branch had some end of line router bits in stock, so I
made a special journey to go and buy some. Looked around for a while and
finally asked for assistance. Kid told me they had definitely sold out.
Absolutely, definitelu, positively.\\Next day a friend bought two boxes of
bits from the same store, so I went back the day after that. This time they
HAD sold out.. Grrrr!
I've had experiences of being sent the full length of the store (a big one)
by an assistant to find a more appropriate/quialified assistant (?) and then
had to travel the _full_ length of the store again to the section where I
made the initial enquiry.. this has happened on several occasions, when I had
a sprained ankle and was hardly able to walk, even with the stick I was
leaning on. No offer to find/page the appropriate staff member at the initial
point of enquiry.
Crap staff, generally. There are some exceptions, so when you find one, keep
him/her for your very own and treasure him/her for future contact but the
chances are they will have moved on by the next time you use the branch..
That said, there is some good stuff in store, if you know what you want and
what the market is. Their own brand power tools can be superb or mediocre
depending on what's available. Fasteners are extortionately expensive, sheet
goods _can_ be quite competitive (full sheets) or a total rip-off, as I
found when I took a half sheet (unmarked price) to the checkout and found it
was a quid cheaper than a full sheet.
Buy the saw though, you'll not regret it if you want brute force and a good
On Fri, 3 Apr 2009 19:00:43 +0100, bib wrote
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.