Is a slim duct mini-split setup enough to cool a whole colonial?

Nov 20, 2026 Last reply: 22 hours ago 3 Replies
Saved reading

First reply

SageSummit

We went a similar route with slim ducts and honestly the concept is solid. They move air just like a regular air handler or furnace would, so the fact that it's not a traditional central setup isn't the problem. The wall-heads-free aesthetic is exactly why people pick them, and…

Read the full reply

So we live in an older colonial, about 1600 sq ft, no AC at all and no way into the attic. Just got a quote back and I'm trying to figure out if it makes sense.



The plan is to put slim duct units in the attic for the second floor, they'd cut in some access to get up there, and more slim ducts in the basement to handle the first floor. Everything ties back to one outdoor unit, a Carrier 37MUHAQ36AA3 ductless Infinity heat pump. The quote also has two Carrier Ecobee thermostats, linesets, a surge protector, overflow safety switches, and insulated duct and runout stuff for the overhead runs. I like that nothing goes on the walls, way better for how the house looks. But it's not really a traditional central AC setup either, and I keep second guessing whether one outdoor unit with two ducts can actually keep the whole place comfortable on a hot day. Has anyone lived with this kind of setup? Anything I should watch out for before I sign off on it?


We went a similar route with slim ducts and honestly the concept is solid. They move air just like a regular air handler or furnace would, so the fact that it's not a traditional central setup isn't the problem. The wall-heads-free aesthetic is exactly why people pick them, and in an old colonial hiding everything in the attic and basement is about the cleanest way to do it. The catch is sizing. That outdoor unit has to carry the whole 1600 sq ft on a hot day, and if it's undersized for your actual heat load you'll be disappointed no matter how nice the install looks. Before you sign anything, ask the contractor for the load calculation results, either a Manual J or an F280. A legit contractor will have run one already. If they can't produce it, that tells you something. The calc should also confirm the supply register locations have been mapped out, because in an old house with no existing ductwork, where the air actually comes out matters a lot for keeping both floors even.

The other thing I'd look at closely is the electrical side of the quote. There's a sub panel in there along with a long run of 6/3 UF cable and Polaris taps, and that's a lot of electrical work for an HVAC crew to be doing themselves. Nothing wrong with the parts necessarily, but I'd want an electrician to review that portion before it's baked into the contract. HVAC guys doing their own electrical can go sideways, and it's easier to sort out now than after wires are pulled. So the setup itself can absolutely work, and I wouldn't talk you out of it. It just all hinges on the numbers. Get the load calc in writing, check the register plan, and have an electrician eyeball the panel work. If those three things check out, you're in good shape.

Looking at your photo, the thing that jumped out at me was the overflow switches on the line items. When I did my own quote shopping that was the part I never thought to ask about untill my wife pointed out the attic is right over our bedrooms, and I ended up caring more about that than half the fancy stuff. Seeing it allready listed in yours would put me at ease. Did the contractor say where those runs overhead are getting insulated duct from, or is it all loose flex in the joist bays?

The overflow switch point in your photo is the one that hits home for me too. When I was getting quotes for my place the switches only showed up because I asked, and once I realized what was sitting above my ceilings I wished they'd just been on the list from the start like they are in yours. Seeing them line-itemed there would honestly reassure me more than anything else on the page. Did the contractor happen to mention where they want the drain line to run for the attic unit? That always seemed to be the part that varies the most between quotes I looked at.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required