Yes, it's on-topic -- I'm rebuilding my dust collection system using
5" spiral pipe. As an aside, I found a manufacturer in Tucson that builds spiral pipe and fittings and was able to get ductwork for less than half what it would have cost to get it from either Penn State or Oneida, even before shipping charges were added. The pipe is pretty good, the elbows and y's leave a little to be desired in terms of fit and finish -- they are more than slightly undersized, there is quite a bit of silicone seal being used to fill gaps between pipe and fittings (up to 1/16"), but I digress. ...I'm using pop rivets to hold the fittings to the pipe and had ordered a pop rivet tool from Penn State. The tool came with a sampler of pop- rivets, 15 each in 4 sizes from 3/32 and up. I used up all but the largest size and went to the blue Borg to get some more. The only thing Lowes had was Arrow 1/8" pop rivets. Using the rivets that came with the tool, I had nary a hiccup. First try using the Arrow brand, the stem stuck in the tool, broken off below the guide -- I had to dis- assemble the tool to get it loose. This particular box had what appear to be a brassy stem (looks kind of like coated nails), vs. the silver of the other rivet stems. I tried some from the second box of Arrow brand I had gotten (Lowes only had one box that was all silver, the rest had the yellowish colored stems). While these did not break off inside the tool, the stem will only self-extract to about 1/4", I then need to use a pliers to remove the stem the rest of the way.
My question, has anybody else had similar experiences? Or is it possible the tool manufacturer uses a non-standard rivet, or is it more likely that the brand I bought today uses rivet stems that are much softer than other manufacturers use?