snip
snip
snip
Seems a bit narrow minded to me. Not much allowance at all for personal preference.
I am wondering if we should tell BB King to throw the well tailed Lucille in the river and pick up a Martin. I am not sure at 80 he would be considered a noob...
Les Paul... tailed Chet Atkins (don't even snicker until you have really explored this man's work)... tailed Jeff Beck... tailed Dickie Betts... tailed Mike Bloomfield... tailed Jerry Garcia... tailed
Hope these guys can forge a place in today's music. And there are so many others that hammer (or hammered) away on those damn electrics their whole long lives(feeling their teenage angst?) like Keith Richards, George Benson, Slash, Joe Perry, Sonny Boy Rollins, T Bone Walker at least part time... maybe not full time... so there could be hope for them, too if they are still with us.
For me, I like it all, and if they find a way to do a more mellow version of a song they like themselves, I think that is fine. I don't want to read too much into it. You know, like "the Walrus is Paul" and "did you notice they are all barefoot". I try to take it as it is, another piece of music from the artist.
Robert