On Sun, 28 Dec 2014 13:35:42 -0500, Don Phillipson wrote:
I have a perennial subscription to CR, so, I should check it.
I hadn't even thought of doing that, mostly because, lately, I've
been disillusioned by Consumers Union.
1. They often test models that I can't find in the store
2. They often test for ridiculous things (like motorcycle engine noise)
3. They often don't test what I need to buy (like pasta makers)
It's amazing what they "care" about sometimes, almost as if every
single person who reads their magazine is a prius-loving sun
worshipper and not a well balanced practical person.
However, I can't say how well or poorly they tested beds, so,
I'll look right now, and let you know, since I have the
automatically renewing subscription anyway.
It seems that these are the comparisons for a Queen sized set.
Sealy Posturepedic Gel Series AP 704-coil Cushion Firm Mattress Set:
Mattress Factory $900
Don Phillipson wrote, on Sun, 28 Dec 2014 13:35:42 -0500:
They updated their mattress buying guide in December 2014.
On price, they summarize by saying "But even if you desperately want the
whole thing over, say thanks anyway and head for the door.
You won’t make it."
On Mon, 29 Dec 2014 07:07:24 +0000, Danny D. wrote:
I read the whole CR article.
It pretty much sucked, as I had expected.
They only tested a handful of mattresses, which, of course,
doesn't include the one I bought or the one which I was
comparing it to.
They did describe the sleazy mattress selling process, in
that they on purpose confuse the buyer, and they said,
more than a few times, that you should pay roughly about
half what the asking price is.
They did objectively measure the firmness, and found that
almost zero of the tested mattresses corresponded to what
the marketing people said it would be like, so they said
any manufacturer indication of firmness was totally useless.
They also objectively measured wear (with a huge roller
going over the bed 30,000 times), but again, all that great
testing is useless when I can't find the mattress they've
tested in the stores.
They said a box spring is a box spring is a box spring, and
even suggested re-using an old box spring instead of buying
a new one (they called it the "foundation").
They did say you never know a bed until you sleep in it,
but, in the store, the best you can do is lay it for at least
15 minutes, which, they said, kind of pretty much sort of
roughly corresponds to sleeping overnight (with a huge margin
of error, based on their surveys).
They also said the number of coils don't matter.
On Mon, 29 Dec 2014 09:28:40 -0500, Mayayana wrote:
I never used the term "top quality", and, anyway, that
your suggestion of buying top quality is not at all the
same thing as "understanding quality".
One is an object.
The other is a process of making a decision.
I've made my decision. I hope it was the right one under
the circumstances. The CR thread was helpful in that it
pretty much said what I had thought all along, which is that
a mattress is a mattress is a mattress unless you can actually
test it overnight and with their 30,000 roller press (which
Box springs make the bed higher than I like.
Don't overlook the traditional bed slat solution:
Lots of choices available.
When we lived in Europe these were called Lattenroste. We're still using the ones we brought back.
On Mon, 29 Dec 2014 09:34:05 -0500, Norminn wrote:
If I was looking at a Picasso painting, then I would have to agree.
But, if I was looking at a block of wood for a stated purpose, I'm
sure the number of knots, the cracks, the hardness, etc, would all
be part of a simple quality metric.
Same with beds. There are simple quality metrics, but not many.
It turns out that buying a mattress is pretty easy, since you can't
reliably test them for comfort anyway (CR had lackluster results
with 1/4 of the people who lay on them for 15 minutes in the store).
Sure, you can kick the tires (ie bounce on the bed a few times),
but that won't tell you all that much, and, CR showed that the
manufacturers' designation of firmness was totally useless (they
tested it objectively with a foot-wide yellow circular press).
Anyway, I already bought it, so, it will arrive today.
Thanks for all the advice.
While I was at the store, getting mine for 1/2 the listed price,
a guy came in, bounced on a few beds, and picked one, and paid
full price (three times what I paid). The other salesperson gave
him the upsell, and, Wow. He bought it all! Some people have a lot
of money to spend!
I agree. I want standard queen-sized sheets to fit. So, I opted for
a normal thickness mattress, which the manufacturer qualified as
"cushion firm", but who knows how firm it really is.
I liked the advice from the saleslady that you can always make a bed
softer but you can't make it firmer. So I opted for the "cushion firm",
which, as CR stated, means nothing (but it doesn't have extra layers
of foam on top of gel on top of foam, etc).
I googled for prices and it seems I couldn't find the price I paid
anywhere so, at least I didn't get badly ripped off.
The mattress I bought was the "Sealy Posturepedic AP 704 Cushion Firm"
which has 704 coils (at the time, I had thought that coil count
matters but CR said it didn't matter at all).
On Mon, 29 Dec 2014 14:44:32 -0500, Ed Pawlowski wrote:
I agree. It's all set up now.
And it is just about the right height!
Total cost was just under $700.
$600 Sealy Posturepedic AP 704 Cushion Firm Mattress & box spring
$ 50 sales tax
$ 40 bed frame
$ 0 delivery
Of course, now I have to learn how to buy sheets.
I think I'll go with nothing less than 400 thread count
at Bed Bath & Beyond.
Sounds like a fair price it is is a decent set. Cosco usually has good
I'd avoid department stores and I'd check the reputation of any mattress
shops. Some are not so good.
Our last buys were from www.mybobs.com if you live in the area they
serve, check them out. As I type this. I'm laying on my Power Bob with
memory foam maytress. Very comfortable and easy to watch TV or type on
a laptop on my belly.
I bought a Sealy at sears. Was about $600 on sale. The problem with new
mattresses is overuse of foam. The foam settles forming a valley. The
mattress really gave off a lot of gasses for a few months. Had to run an
air cleaner. I bought a mattress at a discount store for a little less. I
was happier with that mattress. I would never buy one without trying it out
at the store.
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.