In a recent post I mentioned some other sources for chemicals and
chemical analysis for electrolysis rust removal--in the event that
others, like myself, had a hard time finding "washing soda".
The other day I bought a 2 lb canister of 100% sodium carbonate for $3
and change at Lowes. Look in the pool section (the one I checked had
it in the covered outdoor section) for Spa-Kem pH Plus.
I have no idea what your point is. If you mean that the Na2CO-3 is the
same in both, it isn't. Arm & Hammer washing soda contains other
ingredients. It's got one of the highest concentrations of Na2CO-3,
which makes it ideal for electrolysis, but it's also got
detergents--which may or may not be helpful in electrolysis. They
probably don't affect it much either way since many have used it
But the pool additive is pure Na2CO-3, and it's cheap, AND (the point
of my post) it is more readily available.
Availability, Han, that's the issue I was trying to cover.
See my earlier post at:
Also, I just ran across a site detailing how to make (fairly pure)
Na2CO-3 from Baking Soda (Sodium *Bi*carbonate) at:
email@example.com (Hylourgos) wrote in
I'm sorry, if I irked you. My only point was that Na2CO-3 is Na2CO-3,
whatever you call it. Whether or not the detergents in A&H would help, I
can't tell for sure. My guess is that they would help a little, but I
have no experience whatsoever trying any of this myself.
Not at all--your short post was just enigmatic, and I didn't
understand what you were getting at.
I, and many others, have done electryolysis with plain old Arm&Hammer
Sodium BI-Carbonate, and it seems to work OK. From what I've read and
from what little experience I've had (haven't actually tested them
side-by-side) though, Sodium Carbonate is more effective, the purer
the better. So...I'd always been in search of a cheap and easy source.
When I found it, I wanted to share it.
But I completely understand if someone has tried regular Baking Soda,
it worked for them and they have no desire to try anything else to see
if it works better.
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.