What are the tradeoffs between the following sharpening systems? Japanese waterstones, scary sharp, DMT Diamond stones, Shapton Stones, Lee Valley (LV) Veritas MkII, or Tormek?
Here's my take: (I've only used Japanese waterstones and the scary sharp method.)
The Japanese waterstones aren't cheap but the last a while. A 4000 grit from LV is about $21 for the regular size and $38 for a large. Soaking them in water is a nuisance. Keeping them in the house ('cause they'll freeze in the garage is a hassle, too. They always seems to be in SWMBO's way.). I estimate start up cost to be: $100 -- Lee Valley sells a "professional" kit for $108 -- a deal! This should last a while but not sure how long it last with respect to the other methods.
I tend slightly prefer the scary sharp method over the Japanese waterstones, although it's hard to get more than 2000 grit paper. Plus the paper is more expensive than I thought -- one chisel might use a sheet of 400. A sheet of 1200 and 2000 only last a few sharpenings. Boxes of 50 sheets of the 2000 grit paper are $40. Boxes of 1200, 600,
400 -- only a little cheaper. They also come in packes of 6 sheets or 15 sheets. A friend of mine claims you only need to grits. I've been using 4: 400, 600, 1200, 2000. I hear you can also get 2500 but the store I buy from considers that a special order. It's also a hassle to go to yet another store to buy the 3M 77 adhesive: a can of it is another $13. I can store all this stuff in the garage and there's no water to worry abour. Start up cost plate glass ............... $10 Assortment of sandpaper ... $50 Totoal .................... $60The DMT Diamond stones are "endorsed" by Lie-Nielson:
The Spapton stones aren't cheap either
The MkII seems very convenient. It is certainly cost competive with the DMT Diamond stones and the Shapton stones. You can also apply the scary sharp technique by making your own platters. Start up cost for unit plus two extra platters ... $320
The Tormek seems to be a favorite for folks that sharpen more than chisels and hand plane blease, like turning chisels, etc. It's pricey. Start up cost ... $400
Note: LV also carries ceramic stones (not Shapton -- I don't think), diamond stones (not DMT -- I don't think), aluminum oxide stones. I don't know how they compare but they are cheaper. LV also carries a belt sander. I don't know much about that technique either. Any comments, Robin?
My conclusion: stick with the basic scary sharp method. Sharpen a little more often and run to the automotive paint store for more sandpaper every once in a while. Take the money that I would have spent on the more expensive methods and buy a new hand plane. Am I wrong?