sanding soft and hard woods together?

Nov 24, 2005 6 Replies
Saved reading

First reply

noonenparticular

Rob, I have to respectfully disagree here. I once used a scraper on a row of mortises (craftsman style piece). The scraper cut a *noticeable* dip over the mortise. I would use the handplane in this instance as I *believe* the hard and soft woods would behave the same given the…

Read the full reply

hi, my laminated woodworking project has epai and African mahogany strips in it. kind of like a butcherboard. No matter how straight a backing board I use. (I've even tried marble and tile) the softer wood sands first and I have "dents" where the harder wood is proud. I don't have access to a thickness sander. Any tips? Thank you.


Try using a scraper instead - you should get a more uniform finish.

Rob,

I have to respectfully disagree here. I once used a scraper on a row of mortises (craftsman style piece). The scraper cut a *noticeable* dip over the mortise.

I would use the handplane in this instance as I *believe* the hard and soft woods would behave the same given the curved edge a scraper presents.

YMMV FWIW MY2CW ETCETC AODYCTO

JC

>

Like Rob said, a scraper or a smoother hand plane.

I think you meant ipe for the hard wood. This is very dense. I have some cutoffs from a colleagues deck project where I helped to install the decking.

Perhaps the ipe dust is adding to the abrasion of the mahogany.

I have not tried to plane ipe, but I have planed maple, which is not as dense. Maple is not easy to get an even stroke. Depends on how long the board is. I expect ipe is even harder to plane by hand.

I agree with the suggestion to try scraping. Less dust and can be a smoother result.

Dave Paine.

Have you ever used a scraper that had a straight edge vs. a curved one? Those work a lot like a hand plane.

Actually I don't own a curved edge scraper (didja hear that Santa? Hint Hint.....).

However, I always bow mine outward with my thumbs while scraping. That was the curved edge I was referring to.

Should have said so, but I usually assume everybody is reading my mind. ;-)

jc

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required