A customer called me today and said that the keeper for a lock that we
use for their showcases is screwed into the endgrain of the
particleboard. This connection is failing, they say.
I have my own opinion on this but I would like to know if my fellow
Wreckers think that there is any directionality to particleboard.
I already understand that this is made under a hot press, which
increases the density of the board on its face but, is there any
difference in holding power for a screw driven through the face v. the
edge?
I'm talking about a screw that goes into the board for 1-1/4".
Glad to hear an opinion.
tjwatson1ATcomcastDOTnet (real email)
http://home.comcast.net/~tjwatson1 (webpage)
[snip]
You DO have to use special screws in particle board. Take a look
at this first, then do a search on particle board in their search bar.
http://www.mcfeelys.com/multiple.asp?productID 15-HD
I hate particle board - mdf/hdf/osb - all glue with a waste material
binder. Only place I use it is for the extension table on my
unisaw and on a couple of sliding tables for power tools.
--
I can find no modern furniture that is as well designed and emotionally
satisfying as that made by Gustav Stickley in the early years of the last
If we accept modern as "last 100 years", then we've just missed the
timeslot for a designer you'd surely agree was better than Stickley -
Harvey Ellis. Looking at any of the "Gustav Stickley" designs the
good stuff is Ellis', the lumpy ugly ones are Gustavs. Sadly the
rarity of their sales was such that Gustav's are now rarer and more
valuable.
Although I do accept your general point, it's also a little unfair to
some of the less well-known but equally skilled designers of recent
years - some of whom are working very much in Stickley's (or Ellis')
style itself.
The problem is that these designers don't have a factory behind them.
With no factory, they can never ever get into a "furniture store".
Therefore, for most Americans, they do not exist.
I'm tired of spending thousands of dollars (Henredon and others) on stuff
that is destined to end up at the curb on bulk trash day. From what I
can see as I pass through furniture stores, everything (mass market
oriented) is designed to be "temporary" and discarded as fashions
change next year.
Changed my sig...
--
I can find no modern furniture that is as well designed and emotionally
satisfying as that made by the Arts and Crafts movement in the early years
On Thu, 10 Feb 2005 14:01:38 +0000, the inscrutable Andy Dingley
I saw quite a few Stickley and Ellis/Stickley repros in Anchorage, AK
when I was there a couple years ago. I just love Ellis' stuff!
Yes, indeed. Harvey was Stickley's premier designer. Robert Lang just
put out a book on his inlay work. I hope to be doing some of that in
the near future, along with a few other projects.
Just found this site: http://www.arts-crafts.com when I was searching for
info on another bookcase ( Charles Limbert ). I've started digging up
lots of names because I bought a complete CD-ROM copy of "The Craftsman"
from 1901 through 1916 on eBay. This is the guy I bought it from:
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&itemE26387303
I discovered (much to my amazement) that William Morris the chair designer
also wrote a book that I enjoyed very much.
--
I can find no modern furniture that is as well designed and emotionally
satisfying as that made by the Arts and Crafts movement in the early years
Morris wrote a lot more than one book! He was a 19th Century polymath
who designed everything from furniture to fabrics and wrote books from
fiction to poetry to books on design.
Find some more of his stuff. You're likely to be astonished at his range
and inspired by his thoughts on design.
--RC
On 10 Feb 2005 23:53:33 GMT, the inscrutable Ed Clarke
Looks interesting. Is it worth the steep price? I have over a dozen
very nice A&C books now, including 2 of Lang's Craftsman furniture
books and the latest, "Shop Drawings for Craftsman Inlays & Hardware :
Original Designs by Gustav Stickley and Harvey Ellis" (Shop Drawings
series)
He was a prolific author. His fabric designs are still being
reproduced by Sanderson in GB. Lovely stuff going for a mere
$40 to $60/yd. <thud> http://www.sanderson-uk.com
What you get is eight CD-ROMs with pdf files of each issue of "The
Craftsman". The files are searchable and printable with one exception.
The "Index" file is a modern compilation that includes the table of
contents of every issue and that is not printable except through some
contortions to defeat the no-print security flag.
This is not simply a bunch of plans; it includes things like an
essay by a stained glass worker complaining about how the customer
screws up the "art" and cheapens the product. "12th century stained
glass lasts 700 years exposed to the elements; modern stained glass
needs to be kept behind outer glass due to flimsyness of construction."
I notice a significant number of woman authors in the contents. I'd been
under the impression that women were kitchen dwellers or household
managers at that time (1901-1916). Guess I was wrong, at least in the
A&C community.
All in all, I'm glad that I spent the $50. I'm learning a lot, and not
just about woodworking.
--
I can find no modern furniture that is as well designed and emotionally
satisfying as that made by the Arts and Crafts movement in the early years
On 11 Feb 2005 15:36:13 GMT, the inscrutable Ed Clarke
That's good! There have always been a few women artists, and
Elizabeth Eaton Burton has always been my favorite of those. Look for
her lamps and leather + hammered copper book covers. Outstanding!
I wish they'd put out a paper version. I'd much rather read things
like that in their original format.
Thanks for the review, Ed.
--
Vidi, Vici, Veni
---
http://diversify.com Comprehensive Website Development
I'm always a bit surprised at the number of women who influenced
history. We've been taught that men did everything and women stayed home
to raise kids and run the house but it just wasn't true. There were many
women involved outside the home in the A&C movement and history in
general- not just laborers, but real innovators and influential. Names
escape me at the moment, but I know I've read at least a few instances
of women running companies plus taking over ownership when their
husbands died. Just fer instance, Charles R. Makintosh's wife was a
designer in her own right and they partnered with another husband and
wife couple in Glasgow. I don't remember her name because the sexism, at
that time and since, has generated more recognition for her husband. Sad
really.
--
Owen Lowe and his Fly-by-Night Copper Company
____
"Sure we'll have fascism in America, but it'll come disguised
Kidding about what? That some clown paid 150K or that it was a bad car?
*G*
The Barrett Jackson auction site will have more to say about it.
May have been a special engine/transmission combo...limited production?
Who knows?.... but 150 grand?? Hell, that's more money than all the
tools in the Festool catalogue!!!
150 grand?? That's an upgrade to my home theatre set-up...like a NEW
HOME!
Of the mass market manufacturers of the time, I think many of Limbert's
designs are outstanding and set themselves apart from the Stickley's.
The cutouts and gothic arches, I find very appealing. I would agree with
Ellis' designs too - especially the beautiful inlay pieces.
The Roycrofters is a puzzler to me - they branded almost all of their
furniture with a big ol' Roycroft logo right on the very front. Signing
one's work is one thing, but sheesh.
Of course, as I'm sure you know, the A&C movement was all about honoring
the individual artisan and craftsman and rejecting the factory clones
brought about by industrialization of the late Victorian era. It was
about purposeful design and not merely because the technology to stamp
out thousands of copies of an intricate design by machine was now
possible. (Just because one can do something doesn't mean it adds value
to the end product.) The irony is that the very movement that honored
the skill of the individual was appropriated by mass production
factories wherein the worker was just an operator of a machine.
--
Owen Lowe and his Fly-by-Night Copper Company
____
"Sure we'll have fascism in America, but it'll come disguised
On Fri, 11 Feb 2005 01:29:05 -0800, Fly-by-Night CC
Limbert ?! I find their stuff indeed distinctive, but the random
arches and mad cutouts have more in common with '60s sub-Tolkien than
with the Gothic period.
Is there any truth in the rumour that the Seven Dwarves' house in
Disney's Snow White was furnished in Limbert designs ?
http://www.treadwaygallery.com/ONLINECATALOGS/March2004/ACWEB/0034.jpg
I'm planning on building a couple of the smaller ones (#34 jpg).
Funny you should say that! The last couple times I've seen the movie (I
have a young daughter who plays her movies over and over and over), I
thought, "It would be so cool to have a house like that. The carved
door, owl stairs and everything."
--
Owen Lowe and his Fly-by-Night Copper Company
____
"Sure we'll have fascism in America, but it'll come disguised
===========================.
I also watched in amusement for what these cars sold for...
I am an older lifelong "Car Freak" and have a 68 SS 396 Chevelle and
5 older Corvettes resting until spring in my garages right now...
But the fact remains that the value of some cars when fully documented
and equipped the right way .....and ... stripped models that were
ordered from the factory with very high performance engines under
their hoods...etc... were equipped the right way... .
No I would not pay 150 big ones for the Satellite nor would I have
paid 350 big ones for the Chevelle that sold at the same auction..
these were very exceptional and rare cars that were offered for sale
at the right time to the right crowd...
I only wish that I could now Infer or say my Chevelle is worth 175 Big
ones because it is very similar to the one that sold for 350K....
heck 20K is much more like its true value...and even at that price it
would not sell in a day or two...
Bob Griffiths
[snip]
Ohh, don't get me wrong, I love a nice car as much as the next guy,
maybe even more. I'd drop 300 big ones on the right Bentley. TWO
problems though...the right Bentley would cost 5 times that and I don't
have 300 grand.
...
Wellll i gots my own thoughts on PB as well but we wont go into that!
lol.. :-]> as far as i can tell its all end grain! however screws do
seem to hold better into the face side. you absolutely must pre bore
it though as i'm sure you are aware. and glue the heel outta it too !
is there some way to incorporate real wood into the mix where the lock
is? just a thought.
skeez
I have see the presses that make this stuff and have learned the
manufacturing process. DAMW!
These boards are actually (usually) multi layered - again most boards
are 4 to 6 layers. (Fiber, resin, fiber, resin, fiber,resin, fiber -
then cook in the press - cookie sheet or continuous roller style) There
is "some orientation" of the fibers in particle board and fiber board.
Again - depends on the board and the manufacturer. Been through a lot of
plants... Never saw any that weren't like this - but somebody always
knows more. :-)
There is a normally a finer layer of fibers on the outside (face) of the
board (except -- I think -- on the very coarsest boards - the Oriented
Strand Board -- OSB style). My own experience is that screws hold better
on the face - not the ends. probably this is due to the press action and
a greater compression 90 deg. to the face of the board.
Next time you are in the lumber yard take a close look at the
construction of the different styles -- you should be able to see the
layers. MDF is usually the easiest to see the layering.
Just wear a dust mask when you cut that crud.
Tom Watson wrote:
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.