Having a home made router table top is great, BUT, it must be absolutely dead flat. So you might want to double check that if you have not done so. If there are low or high spots the jig will not perform accurately. And high and low can be just a slight amount to throw things off. With a long jig the deviation can multiply results and DT's are notorious for being finicky with proper fit.
Just something to double check before committing.
As some of us here here have found, when you start expecting better accuracy you have to have the right set up and more elements begin to matter more.