It's getting to be time to replace my old cordless Craftsman drill/driver, and I think I've narrowed my choices to two or three. I'll be using this primarily for driving square-drive wood screws, but it may see the occasional drill bit or socket. My choices include
1.) a Makita 12V impact driver (6914), 2.) a Panasonic 12V 3/8" drill/driver (EY6405FQKW), 3.) or possibly a Bosch 9.6V impact driver (23609-RT). All come with two, 2.0 amp-hr, NiCad batteries. Price (both drivers are reconditioned) is close enough to be negligible, in the $100ish range. My thoughts so far: I've heard that an impact driver is great for driving screws - fast, lots of torque, and easy on the wrist, while being light and maneuverable. I've also heard that Panasonic makes the best batteries around, and I've seen several good reviews of their drills. Price and weight (all of these claim 3.5-4.0 lbs) are probably more important to me than the run time of higher-voltage tools. My main questions: Since the impact drivers apparently don't have an adjustable clutch, is it harder to prevent over-tightening? It seems like I'd have less control over that. Also, I know impact drivers aren't meant to drill holes, but will it work acceptably for occasional use? (I might eventually get a keyless chuck on a 1/4" hex shank to use standard bits). What are your thoughts? Other pros/cons I haven't thought of? Has anyone used any of these specific models? Should I hold out and pay $200 for a Panasonic NiMH or Makita Li-Ion drill? TIA, Andy- posted
17 years ago