Hi,
I made a wooden spoon for my wife from some scrap cherry and everybody wants one. That's fine, and they ship better than nightstands so it's great for the relatives a thousand miles away. The cherry spoons look great so I started experimenting.
Got some beautiful BE maple from craigslist. My wife got one of the first birdseye maple spoons and that's my question.
I finish them all with walnut oil because it dries hard and I'd prefer not to use mineral oil. With the cherry, that's fine. They keep that nice rich finish no matter how much they get used.
But the maple, no. Just use it once and it gets that washed out whiteish look, as though it was never finished. I've re-oiled it twice. The first time, I warmed the spoon and the oil to about 150 degrees in the oven.
But one use still makes the birdseye look washed out. It's a great display spoon and it works fine as a tool if you don't mind that it's not nearly as pretty any more. :-)
Is this something that happens to birdsey maple spoons or have I just gotten an odd sample of it? I'm going to experiment with mineral oil just to see what happens, but several family members have said they would prefer unfinished over mineral oil. So far everyone likes the walnut oil finish. I'm thinking of mixing beeswax in with the walnut.
No problem finding other things to do with the wood. I'm just surprised there's so much difference in behavior between the cherry and the maple. To me, it seems more difference than I'd expect just because the cherry's darker.