Paying a plumber cash in hand is "morally wrong" because it denies the
revenue vital funds, a Treasury minister said as the government outlined
new ways of cutting down on £5bn in tax avoidance.
David Gauke, the exchequer secretary to the Treasury, risked shining a
spotlight on whether any of his government colleagues have ever made
cash in hand payments to plumbers when he described the practice as a
large part of Britain's "hidden economy".
Trades poeple operate to current moral norms, as displayed by bankers,
politicians, journalists, entertainers, pro footballers etc. Is that news?
Its bloody silly.
We should not tax the things we want to happen, like working. We should
tax the things we need to reduce, like fuel, smoking, and importing
materials and finished goods.
I have long advocated a state pension age related (but not work related)
that replaces the complex system of the dole and benefits, and zero
income tax, with infinitely more taxes raised on the sale on non
subsistence goods. Then scrap the minimum wage, because its no longer
needed as people get the pension whether they work or not.
There are issues of policing BUT it has the following advantages
- people who live here pay the sales and import taxes on goods bought
here. And high earners will WANT to live here. The presence of slots of
stinkingly rich people here with miney to burn can only be goodm,, even
if luxury goods are expensive.
- the labour market is totally flexible. People can work when they like
for who they like - they lose no benefits by working - at anything at
all. From fruit picking to washing cars and polishing your boots.
- because the state pension is limited to those who are actually born
here, not those who arrive (tough, but fair) low income people will not
find it easy to immigrate. However high earners to whom the state
pension is almost an irrelevance, will.
- because taxation is not applied to subsistence goods - essentially
food clothing and other basics - lower paid workers will be massively
subsidised and be able to compete well with offshore workers without any
directives needing to be applied. If the state pension is say Â£3.50 and
hour you only need pay - say - Â£3 an hour on top of that to employ
someone at a living wage and with no tax or NI to pay its not a bad crack.
- Because imported goods and materials are now expensive, there is a
huge incentive to recycle refurbish and repair. Essentially it baises
the national economy towards re-use and away from consumer buy and trash.
- naturally this free market in labour with the government simply not
caring about who earns what - only what they spend and what they spend
it on - would require exit from the EU. Well, so what?
Its time we put Britain first, and British workers, yea even unto the
man who cuts your grass.
To people who know nothing, anything is possible.
To people who know too much, it is a sad fact
So why did you do it then, you fuckwit liar?
Oh while you're at it, why don't you just fuck off? You're as welcome here
as in any other newsgroup you infest - i.e, as welcome as a turd topping on
an ice cream sundae.
diy.org> escribió:>You really are a sad case, aren't you
Time for a quick repost:
Rod Speed FAQ: http://tinyurl.com/883xp7v
Why would you do that you fuckwit? Do you always force yourself into
conversations where someone doesn't want to hear what you have to say? Do
you spend a lot of time getting smacked in the teeth in pubs? Or are you
just the Billy-No-Mates you make yourself out to be here?
On 24/07/2012 11:02, 78u77 wrote:
none of you use hospitals, you all pay for your medical aid ?
any of you ever had a receipt of a chinese or any take away, do they pay
their taxes based on what they take? people are fiddling their tax and
they still expect to get everything for nothing.don't complain about
people getting benefits while most of you don't even contribute to the
tax and N.I. that pays for it.
I used to feel bad about the odd fiddle. Now I do not, because I see the
government wasting my money on wars based on lies, bankers being bailed out
of their own self inflicted failure, and big fat contracts worth billions
being awarded to the incompetant like G4S for no good reason.
Paying cash is not necessarily 'bent' - AFAIK unlike consumer bank accounts,
business bank accounts charge per transaction so there is a cost in putting
a cheque through the bank.
As long as you get a valid receipt (VAT receipt where applicable) then
paying some of the bills with cash which is then recycled by the
tradesperson on every day expenditure is in no way wrong.
Obviously the suggestion by the consumer to the tradesperson that they "Pay
cash, nudge, nudge, wink, wink, no names no pack drill no VAT and no income
tax" is encouraging the tradesperson to contrave the taxation laws.
At least we are not as paranoid as some Nordic countries where tax is/was so
high that people went to a cashless economy and traded skills; "You mend my
car and I'll paint your house" and similar. Whereupon they changed the law
so that you had to declare all services done for other people regardless of
if you were paid or not.
Makes casual sex a finacially risky proposition.
A charity f*ck should now appear on your income tax form.
Please, not in this country!
No plan survives contact with the enemy.
[Not even bunny]
They'll be reintroducing schedule A tax next, for such services. As in:
Let's see, you just did the washing up, vacuumed the house, and cut the
grass. That took you four hours. You might have employed someone at say
Â£8/hour to do that, so Â£32 there. We want 20% of that, so Â£6.40 please.
"That excessive bail ought not to be required, nor excessive fines imposed,
Indeed... also what has how has the recipients tax affairs got anything
to do with the person paying the bill?
Not only that, what are the alternatives? They can either take a cheque
at a huge risk of not getting paid, or they can shell out hundreds a
quarter to their bank for card payment facilities and a merchant account.
That is already the case here... or at least HMRC would have you
believe. If you "give away" a service that you would normally derive
income from, they still expect you to pay the tax on the notional value!
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.